Staredit Network > Forums > Null > Topic: Roy's Mod Mafia: Game 1
Roy's Mod Mafia: Game 1
Oct 1 2010, 3:11 pm
By: Roy
Pages: < 1 2 3 4 5 629 >
 

Oct 5 2010, 4:27 pm poison_us Post #61

Back* from the grave

http://www.staredit.net/262895/

Quote from poison_us
Quote from name:Azrael.Wrath
Again, please quote the rule where it says "You may not request or volunteer a quote from a role PM."
Quote from Leeroy_Jenkins
Quote from DT_Battlekruser
C. One may not request or volunteer screenshots, videos, etc. of another's role screen or someone's password via the thread, a PM, or any other method. The game is intended to be won via behavioral analysis, special roles, and praying a lot. Such exchanges will be punished severely and take place at your own risk.
SEN Mafia XV: Gotham City
You know perfectly well that it's against the rules, just like I did when I made the video of my role.

Roy, before Azrael continues with this, please update the rules to explicitly ban any and all sharing of roles, either by quotations, videos, voice chat, text, cell phone calls, pictures, morse code, code embedded in any of the above, and any other form of communication you deem fit.


Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Oct 5 2010, 4:28 pm by poison_us. Reason: ew, ninja'd...




Oct 5 2010, 5:21 pm Azrael Post #62



Quote
C. One may not request or volunteer screenshots, videos, etc. of another's role screen or someone's password via the thread, a PM, or any other method.

Since some people have reading comprehension problems and apparently have never participated in any previous Mafia games, it's not against the rules to copy and paste your role PM to someone else. As multiple people have stated already, this is the way it has always been. You cannot share screenshots, videos, or other solid evidence of your role, such as sharing your password.

In case you don't understand what "etc" means, it means to include additional items which are relevant to the previous ones. In this case, it obviously means other forms of definitive proof.

Quote from poison_us
I did when I made the video of my role.

Of course you broke the rule when you made the video of your role. The rule explicitly states you cannot make a screenshot or video of your role, so yes, of course you knew you were breaking the rules.

Again, this is the same rule used in TKG. There's a reason why quotes are allowed but screenshots and videos aren't.

Quote from poison_us
Roy, before Azrael continues with this, please update the rules to explicitly ban any and all sharing of roles, either by quotations, videos, voice chat, text, cell phone calls, pictures, morse code, code embedded in any of the above, and any other form of communication you deem fit.

Roy already addressed this :rolleyes: Like every other Mafia game ever, you can share your role by copy and pasting it.

Post has been edited 3 time(s), last time on Oct 5 2010, 5:28 pm by Azrael.Wrath.




Oct 5 2010, 7:24 pm Wing Zero Post #63

Magic box god; Suck it Corbo

Alright we could continue this pointless argument all we want but since it
Quote from name:Dark_Marine
requires a paid subscription.
I think we should move on to more pressing matters.

So who is in Los Angeles now? Let's meet up :D /jk

PS I think Roy is mafia





Oct 5 2010, 7:38 pm Leeroy_Jenkins Post #64



Azrael,

Quote
The game is intended to be won via behavioral analysis, special roles, and praying a lot.

Which of those categories does quoting a PM from the game host fall under?



None.

Oct 5 2010, 7:41 pm Neki Post #65



I have no idea why you guys are making such a big deal out of this, mafia has always allowed you trying to be sneaky or tricky by claiming to "quote" your PM, given the fact that they can't verify it's real or not, you're basically doing a leap of faith if you choose to believe them. There is a risk and reward behind it, unlike other forms of evidence where it is all reward.



None.

Oct 5 2010, 7:42 pm Wing Zero Post #66

Magic box god; Suck it Corbo

Quote from Leeroy_Jenkins
Azrael,

Quote
The game is intended to be won via behavioral analysis, special roles, and praying a lot.

Which of those categories does quoting a PM from the game host fall under?
This one :massimo:




Oct 5 2010, 7:47 pm Azrael Post #67



It also helps with behavioral analysis. You have to determine if you believe it's real or fabricated. If you want to share your role, you have to decide who you trust telling. You could post it in the thread, but then Mafia would kill you.

Anyways, it's a non-issue, just a couple trolls trying to get a reaction from people. It has always been allowed.




Oct 5 2010, 7:55 pm Leeroy_Jenkins Post #68



It's not behavioral analysis. If three people claimed doctor with a role quote, you could figure out which one was lying, via. illegitimate means. It won't be allowed in my mafia. And stop being so dramatic, I'm not trying to get a reaction from people. I was just proving you wrong.



None.

Oct 5 2010, 8:06 pm Azrael Post #69



Quote from Leeroy_Jenkins
If three people claimed doctor with a role quote

Then the two real Doctors will be immediately killed by the Mafia? Oh, alright.

Quote from Leeroy_Jenkins
I was just proving you wrong.

Yes, you proved everyone wrong :rolleyes: Every previous Mafia game has been wrong, the rules are written wrong, and everyone in this thread is wrong. You are right, good job, congratulations. I hope you feel excellent now.




Oct 5 2010, 8:46 pm Ashamed Post #70

Hear me Raor!!

Is it too late for me to sign up??



None.

Oct 5 2010, 8:49 pm Neki Post #71



Ashamed is back?! Where have you been? ;)



None.

Oct 5 2010, 9:06 pm poison_us Post #72

Back* from the grave

Quote from Neki
Where have you been? ;)
You dirty boy, you :teach: [/finishsentences]





Oct 5 2010, 9:18 pm Norm Post #73



Quoting a role PM is a valid strategy in games where a generic role PM is sent. If the hosts wants to prevent this from being used, he can utilize a non-uniform role PM. What's the big deal?



None.

Oct 5 2010, 9:50 pm Roy Post #74

An artist's depiction of an Extended Unit Death

Quote from Ashamed
Is it too late for me to sign up??
Kinda. I'll sign you up anyway. You can thank Derqua for being untimely.
Quote from Leeroy_Jenkins
It's not behavioral analysis. If three people claimed doctor with a role quote, you could figure out which one was lying, via. illegitimate means.
Not in my game :awesome: [/hint]




Oct 5 2010, 9:56 pm poison_us Post #75

Back* from the grave

Quote from Roy
Quote from Ashamed
Is it too late for me to sign up??
Kinda. I'll sign you up anyway. You can thank Derqua for being untimely.
Quote from Leeroy_Jenkins
It's not behavioral analysis. If three people claimed doctor with a role quote, you could figure out which one was lying, via. illegitimate means.
Not in my game :awesome: [/hint]
You're sending out all role PMs to everyone, but then on like the next day or something sending our real PMs, with just one sentence changed (this is your real role PM), aren't you? Lawd, that's even better than sending a townie PM to all, followed by a special role PM only to specials :awesome:





Oct 5 2010, 10:02 pm Azrael Post #76



I think he's doing it the opposite way. Instead of making them so generic that anyone can figure out what they look like, he's going to make them all grossly different (so each player will get a role PM unique to them).




Oct 5 2010, 10:46 pm Roy Post #77

An artist's depiction of an Extended Unit Death

Alright, all checks are confirmed, so roles will be sent out later tonight. Depending on how much time I have, the first game post may also occur tonight. Otherwise, it will be there tomorrow morning.




Oct 5 2010, 10:51 pm TiKels Post #78



Is it too late to sign up? I think I might be like 4 minutes late.



"If a topic that clearly interest noone needs to be closed to underline the "we don't want this here" message, is up to debate."

-NudeRaider

Oct 5 2010, 11:34 pm Aristocrat Post #79



Quote from Leeroy_Jenkins
It's not behavioral analysis. If three people claimed doctor with a role quote, you could figure out which one was lying, via. illegitimate means. It won't be allowed in my mafia. And stop being so dramatic, I'm not trying to get a reaction from people. I was just proving you wrong.

ERROR_PROOF_NOT_FOUND

Banning role PM quotes is stupid. It's just as stupid as banning public role claims and any PM exchange between mafia participants.



None.

Oct 5 2010, 11:52 pm ImagoDeo Post #80



Quote from Aristocrat
Quote from Leeroy_Jenkins
It's not behavioral analysis. If three people claimed doctor with a role quote, you could figure out which one was lying, via. illegitimate means. It won't be allowed in my mafia. And stop being so dramatic, I'm not trying to get a reaction from people. I was just proving you wrong.

ERROR_PROOF_NOT_FOUND

Banning role PM quotes is stupid. It's just as stupid as banning public role claims and any PM exchange between mafia participants.

I agree. Subterfuge is a good thing.



None.

Options
Pages: < 1 2 3 4 5 629 >
  Back to forum
Please log in to reply to this topic or to report it.
Members in this topic: None.
[01:34 am]
da real donwano -- I realize I contradicted myself there. Quit making maps after 9ine failed, officially retired during EUD's.
[01:26 am]
da real donwano -- Very quickly, however, the map was deemed a failure due to people exploiting the SCV repair ability & I just quit making maps after that.
[01:25 am]
da real donwano -- It was a huge success overnight. 10's of people played it multiple (2) times.
[01:24 am]
da real donwano -- "9ine" ... It was a FFA style map on classic BGH. The goal was to be the first one to accumulate EXACTLY 9 minerals.
[01:23 am]
da real donwano -- Luckily, I finished one map & one map only to completion.
[01:23 am]
da real donwano -- Then EUD's showed up & I wasn't smart enough to figure them out. So my map making days ended.
[01:23 am]
da real donwano -- I first started SC back in like 1999. IDK when I first started making UMS myself. But for many, many years I kept trying. I got pretty decent with triggers.
[2024-7-12. : 6:41 pm]
Ultraviolet -- don't threaten me with a good time
[2024-7-12. : 3:25 pm]
Vrael -- you know, that sounds like fun
[2024-7-12. : 1:56 pm]
Oh_Man -- threaten me with completing tenebrous, that would really scare me straight i promise
Please log in to shout.


Members Online: malcolmgdbecker, Roy