If poison hadn't gone haywire and basically made sure we'd lynch him instead of BIO who was the more logical choice at that point we could actually have won.
Because yes, after night 4 I grew suspicious of Roy and thats why I told Demon to "test" him by hitting his bullet proof vest. He dies, he's mafia, he survives, he's bulletproof. Little did I know he was both, but it wouldn't have mattered as he gave away his vest the same night.
At the same time I wasn't so sure of Demon and Vrael anymore, so maybe we would've gotten another Mafia if Demon had decided to cooperate with me. But yeah, nobody ever listens to me unless they are mafia.
Well if we hadn't declared Vrael hub I would've contacted ray (at all) and demon (earlier) so maybe we could've gotten something organized, but when a Mafia manages to become hub it's almost always too late when people start to realize their mistakes.
I got the clue against BIO atk and was pretty sure it's legit the 2nd time it was used.
I also realized "hot" is a clue, but trusted Vrael too much to suspect him at that time. Could have changed if my suspicions had more time to grow though.
I noticed the 15 edits, but didn't care at that time anymore because clearly nobody wanted to work with me, so I let things play out.
Kudos to Roy and Vrael who were the only 2 people I told my role ( ) and still let me live. I had fun while I was alive, even though I now know I was fooled. WP.
I don't like the idea of not being informed of action results. I can excuse the doctor from that because in Devlins setting he doesn't save people, he prevents the hit from happening by being there. But how can someone possibly not know when he was thrown into jail for 1 night? O.o (I know it's just supposed to be a mechanic of non-information, but I still like it when things make sense.) Also this should've been announced somewhere. Noticing it midgame is lame. Or did I miss it somewhere?
I don't like short day and night cycles. Original SEN mafia had 3 days per phase, which was more strategic.
I didn't like that DevliN announced that he won't explain things during the game. I disliked even more that he kept breaking his own rule.
But that's about it. Everything else was really good. Thanks Devlin for hosting such a well organized and interesting game.
The standard victory condition of Mafias is that Mafia wins as soon as they are not outnumbered anymore (which was met). I don't know why DevliN changed it for his game but then decided to go with the old one regardless, but I'm not miffed. We wouldn't have won at that point.