If I would create a rock band, I would definitely pick those guys (I may write their name wrong):

Singer: Jym Morrisson (The Doors) OR Peter Gabriel (Genesis)
Synthetiser: The Doors' OR Emerson, Lake and Palmer's
Lead Guitar: David Gilmour (Pink Floyd)
Guitar #2: Jimy Page (Led Zeppelin)
Bass: Roger Waters (Pink Floyd) OR Sting
Drum: Phil Collins (Genesis)
Flute: Jethro Tull

What would you think of that band?

I would like to have Mike Shinoda in the band. He is the MC in LinkinPark and a singer in Fort Minor.

If I could make a band, I'd go with: John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison and Ringo Starr. Sound like good band?

Doesn't even comes near to David Gilmour alone, lol. He doesn't even need a drummer to make good songs, nor a bassist

Vocals - Craig Owens, Chiodos
Guitar - Chris Broderick, Megadeth
Bass - The Flea, Red Hot Chili Peppers
Drums - Joey Jordison from Slipknot and sequenced breakbeats. Why? Why not?

And me on synth.

>_>;;

Vocals 1/Tambourine - Liam Gallagher (Oasis)
Bowed Guitar / Vocals 2 - Jón Þór Birgisson (Sigur Ros)
Vocals 3 - Steve Perry (Journey)
Drums/Percussion - Neil Peart (Rush)
Bass - Flea (Red Hot Chili Peppers)
Acoustic Guitar - Kyle Gas (Tenacious D)
Rhythm Guitar 1 - Thom Yorke (Radiohead)
Rhythm Guitar 2 - Sam Roberts
Lead Guitar 1 - Buckethead
Lead Guitar 2 - Joe Satriani

A good band NEEDS 3 singers and 6 guitarists.

I would have Britney Spears and all the members of Slipknot together

Vocals - Anthony Green (Formerly in Saosin, now in Circa Survive, and solo work.If you don't know this man, you're missing out on one of the best voices of our time.)
Guitar/Vocals - Claudio Sanchez (Coheed and Cambria)
Guitar/Vocals - Leighton Antelman (Lydia)
Guitar - Travis Stever (Coheed and Cambria)
Bassist - Nick Beard (Circa Survive. This man radiates awesome.)
Drums - Josh Eppard (Coheed and Cambria, formerly)
Keyboard/Vocals - Mindy White (Lydia)

Circa Survive is perfect as it is, fail.

YES! AMAZING LINE UP! I would make Neil Peart (from Rush) on drums though, amazing drummer.
But flute?

Andrew's line-up is basically just one band...

EDIT: Whoops, Neil Peart was already said.

The Synths from The Killers, and the singer from Maroon 5, I don't really care much about the rest

Maroon 5? Next.

You can't deny that guy has the most unique voice ever, and he has a good range.

But does he have an amazing range?

Anthony Green destroys him.

Glad to see people are participating
I agree with Rush's drummer, but to my eyes, he's only the second best drummer of all times. Phil Collins is better, in my opinion.

@MA: Wtf britney Spears? ROCK band...
@Falk: Lmfao? Maroon 5?

Btw, good job for Sigur Ros, great idea ;P

Some would say that the 1969 line-up of the Buckaroos was the best line-up in any band in the history of American music.

For that, I believe, if anyone wants a really good line-up that they should add Buck Owens to their lists!

Vocals: John Cale
Lead Guitar: Buck Owens
Rhythm Guitar: Joe Maphis
Bass Guitar: Les Claypool
Drums: Keith Moon

WTF? Two country guitarist?- Yes, but just imagine them on distorted guitars with the gain on 'hi' and the overdrive exploding at 10! Especially Maphis, he just kicks the shit out of any fast alternate strummers in today's music.

WTF? Les Claypool?- (lol) He is the only great bassist I could think of, and I did not want to add a second member of The Who in there. John Entwistle is awesome, however!

WTF? Three of the people on your list are dead!- Yes, that is a problem...

(lol) Based on what I have read from this...

Vocals: Mick Jagger
Vocals: David Byrne
Vocals: Morrissey
Guitar: Paul Gilbert
Guitar: Nuno Bettencourt
Guitar: Eddie Van Halen
Guitar: Yngwie Malmsteen
Guitar: John 5
Guitar: Synyster Gates
Drums: Charlie Benante

Too epic?

Everyone who says Flea from RHCP as bassist, I aprove.
I will post mine when I decide to stop being biased

This man knows things.