Proposals would be too annoying, moderators would have to view them all, we want to make this as automated as possible.
No it wouldn't be too annoying. You're just lazy.
Proposals would not be annoying if done properly by the users. What would be annoying is, like DT_Battlekruser said, all of the "OMFG WTF WHY WAS MINE DENIED?!?! FUCK YOU!!" that may almost certainly arise.
Maybe for low warns nothing is needed and it slowly decays, but then if you have a really high (maybe, as an arbitrary number, 70%) warn you can petition. That seems fair to me because it could bring out those who may want to stay (and not just trolls), so then moderators (and, perhaps, users) could decide "Do we really want to keep this person here?" If decided to stay thier warn decays, else they get banned, suspended, or whatever action is deemed appropriate. This wouldn't get all cluttery because a very small population ever gets really high (that I've observed) and then all the minor offenses are dealt with automatically.
(By the way, I'm just throwing out a random idea that puts both automation and petitioning/proposals together.
I do agree with most of what Falkoner has been saying.)
I say maybe a 1% decay every 3 days WHEN ACTIVE, and the temporary log should be for judging the current punishment, but a permanent log should also be kept.
Sounds really nice. The users can't just hide away until 0%, you can see the recent offenses to base punishments off of, and then you can also see the everything the user has done for more extreme decisions.
TinyMap2 - Latest in map compression! ( 7/09/14 - New build! )
EUD Action Enabler - Lightweight EUD/EPD support! (ChaosLauncher/MPQDraft support!)
EUDDB -
topic - Help out by adding your EUDs! Or Submit reference files in the References tab!
MapSketch - New image->map generator!
EUDTrig -
topic - Quickly and easily convert offsets to EUDs! (extended players supported)
SC2 Map Texture Mask Importer/Exporter - Edit texture placement in an image editor!
This page has been viewed [img]http://farty1billion.dyndns.org/Clicky.php?img.gif[/img] times!