My use of the word "adequately" in that quote was meant to act as a catch-all for those people. That is, to say their abilities are lackluster and therefore they don't count. I'm not sure who "Ian" is though. Is that Farty or someone else? I do know Farty has extensive map making knowledge, although I don't know that I have actually seen any maps of his.
Where are all of the "MUST HAVE" rules for every clan? There are none! What are the "MUST HAVE" for clan standards? All clans don't NEED a clan channel (Clan MM). All calns don't NEED a clan tag (Clan CheF?). All clans don't NEED a leader (communism? In theory it works). All clans don't NEED a genre. A clan could just be a group of friends who call themselves a group of people, with a title.
Clans do not necessarily need a tag or a leader, but good clans usually have both. The primary purpose of a clan is to have a group of people meet together in a designated place in a game to play together or in the case of map making, share knowledge. A clan should therefore have a channel. Additionally, a clan needs members or it isn't really a clan at all. If no one ever comes to your channel to play together and no one shows and pride or loyalty to your clan, your clan does not really exist at all. The primary way to show pride in your clan is a tag or some kind of indication in your Battle.net profile. As I said already, the purpose of a clan is to meet and play together. What is played does not really matter, and it is is not necessary to stick to one specific genre.
These are rather vague requirements but to be too concrete is inappropriate.
Here are all the currently created clans on SEN:
Clan NuccaThere is no question this is not even a real clan. This is just a bunch of vaguely related people, many of whom have not even logged into Battle.net in months or even years. They share no common interests within the game and never meet or play together.
OriginalOriginal may or may not be a real clan. The fact that many of their members associate themselves with other clans seems to suggest that none of them are actually loyal to Original or have any pride in it.
Clan [MM]Virtually every modder on this site claims to be a member of MM. This puts them in a precarious position. For example, if every nation on Earth became one, would it make any sense to continue to refer to the new nation as a "nation" at all? I think not. The same goes for Clan MM, which contains pretty much every modder and ends up not being a clan at all.
Operation OnslaughtHere is a prime example of a real clan. The members show pride in their clan by wearing a tag and often meet together in a single channel in order to play together.
DynastyFour people who probably don't play together or even go on Battle.net. Not a real clan.
Clan ChefChef was almost a real clan, but quickly collapsed when everyone stopped caring. No longer even remotely legitimate.
Godz MinnionzNever heard of it before. Two people, one of whom has constantly been reprimanded for spamming garbage. Almost certainly not a clan.
(U)UnKnOwN ProDucTionZI don't think we have any members besides Kenoli and I at the moment. Not legitimate until that is figured out.
Freedomforce
ApocalypseHq
clan darkness of light
Clan Destined to Kill
Dangerous Bastards
Prey To The LORD All MigthyOne member. None of these are clans.
Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Sep 23 2007, 12:04 am by Esponeo.
None.