| Tuxedo-Templar | May 14 2008, 7:15 am | Post #101 |
|
I agree. There shouldn't be any reason to be afraid or secretive here. We're not playing some dumb mafia game.
|
||
|
This post was edited 2 times, last edit by Tuxedo-Templar: May 14 2008, 7:37 am.
|
| A_of-s_t | May 14 2008, 1:34 pm | Post #102 |
|
Master of Temptation, Ruler of Aeronotics, and Secret Lover
|
If no one notices moderation then they're doing a good job. That is, unless they're just letting everything run haywire. I would have to disagree.. the disciplinary aspect of moderation should be public so as to establish a precedent for stopping wrongdoing and making it clear what is okay and what isn't. That's half the problem since all the Staff were fired. Anyway, I think Minimoose is going to fix the crappy DLDB -- so, yay! |
||
![]() From silent: "lolol First of all wikipedia is flawed because anyone can come into it and post anything. About criticism.. no. You can't just change the definition of a word and expect everyone to bow down in awe. I am using macro evolution as an identifier between changing from one kind to another kind. I.E. bananas turning into flies. So if you want to argue about this then your argueing about the definition of a word.. Not the theory itself. If you want I can use false evolution, or neverbeenseenbefore evolution instead of macro. Its up to you" This is stupidity. Please look at it very closely -- notice that almost every logical fallacy is used in it. |
| poiuy_qwert | May 14 2008, 6:27 pm | Post #103 |
|
PyMS Developer
|
Please offer me suggestions on how I can help you guys out... instead of silently building resentment. The modding forum setup can be changed. The moderators there can be changed. The prominence of modding info and events can be changed. (though, this iniative of which you speak.... I can't force people, particularily ones that have left, to play your mods.) The fact that I probably won't give you what you don't ask for will not change. Can you please make the little "new post" dot things be a "Go to first unread post" instead of "Go to last post", its REALLY annoying that its not already like that. |
||
|
This post was edited 1 time, last edit by poiuy_qwert: May 14 2008, 6:49 pm.
![]() |
| |
May 14 2008, 8:09 pm | Post #104 |
|
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
|
I think Maplantis's core values are what set it apart from SEN. At Maplantis 1.Ban everyone that was banned on maplantis Overall, in the coding scene, I think the biggest thing isn't neccessarily lots of new things coming, but the idea that the admin was dedicated, and that our features were on the way. Whenever we talked to Yoshi, he would give us updates, and he would listen to our feedback to make the site better. When IP does his coding, he seems to try to come up with some system in his head, that he thinks will work well. Unfortunately, it usually doesn't work well for the people using the system. What I'd like to see happening is the admins talking to the members, making posts, asking for ideas on how to do things, etc. This includes policies. On Maplantis the idea of minerals was discussed, and abandonned because people didn't want it. Here, it was discussed, people didn't want it, and IP made it anyways. This is the kind of thing I'm talking about. Also, it's not simply a matter of banning people who are stupid and or idiots. It's a matter of having a general attitude towards those people. Wheras on Maplantis, if someone acted stupid, members would talk to him about it, ask him to correct his spelling, etc. Also, it was generally considered unacceptable to make off-topic posts. Again, if there was a member-to-member dispute, it would either be kept in PMs, or an admin would come in and clear up the topic for the poor OP. Also, look at the general seriousness of the site. When newbies arrive, they see a bunch of idiots goofing off, admins doing things "for teh lulz", off-topic posts, and they learn from it, and act the same. Maplantis taught new users to be mature, and hard workers. Age doesn't matter, as long as one is capable of acting mature. Also, you get a general idea of what this site is about just by looking at how easy it is to access features. Functions that are related to Starcraft editing get 1/5th of the main menu bar. That's for a site dedicated to starcraft editing!? Maplantis' main menu bar 4/6 of the functions were directly Starcraft-editing related. The forum has equally as much weight on Maplantis as the Wiki or Maps, wheras on SEN someone looking for a map has far more work to do. Simplicity is another big thing. I liked Maplantis' design (not it's skin, its layout), because it's very simple, very sleek, and very professional. Someone looking for maps has a very easy one-click link, followed by a very simple, easy-to-use menu, where he can select maps based on genre, search maps, submit maps, all in a very simple menu. With SEN, one has to click several links to get to a "Database" which is really just all in one, thus removing extreme amounts of organization or simplicity. You're then presented with a complicated, messy, system for sorting maps. I've tried to use it several times, but it's just almost impossible to use easily. Here's another big jump. Imagine SEN, and imagine Maplantis. Now take the forum away. Maplantis is still a very useful and active site, because it has its features weighted in priority correctly. SEN, on the other hand, would become a barren wasteland, an empty site. People would simply stop using it, and it would quickly die. My chief gripe at the moment is about the tendency for the admins (Moose, in particular) to overreact when they feel things have slipped out of control. I agree that the law needs to be laid down, but it often seems that the wrong people end up paying for it. Gmods, such as myself and Syphon, were given their positions because our judgment was sufficiently trusted. But in the case of Jordan, for instance, Syphon made a remark against the person who was basically the site's punching bag. Moose himself allowed Jordan to overstay his welcome. But then, Heranic questioned the morality of Syphon's handling in that topic (which was right of Heranic to do), I think the proper thing to do would have been to PM Syphon about his conduct and tell him not to do it again, or make a post in the staff forum saying that we all need to tighten things up a bit. Firing a loyal member who was ultimately out for the betterment of the site was a bad call, in my opinion. You set the example for our treatment of Jordan by "keeping him around for amusement." You guys are giving us a great resource for free. I'm not forgetting that. But as part of the community, I feel compelled to speak my mind once in awhile. I just think you should remind yourself who your allies are and not sabotage your own efforts for a stable, productive community if that's what you're really after. This block here is a perfect example of why after the majority was begging for latova, we were so sad to be handed v5. No offense IP but i believe the saying 'If it isnt broke, dont fix it.' applied here. The saying doesn't apply to novelty and innovation. StarCraft "ain't broke", why fix it by making mods or maps? |
||
|
This post was edited 2 times, last edit by Mini Moose 2707: May 14 2008, 8:15 pm.
![]() [11:59:05] devilesk: make some allusions to literature [11:59:48] devilesk: make it subtle [12:02:13] Moose: I don't need or want to be told how to make clues. [12:02:19] devilesk: im not telling [12:02:21] devilesk: i'm suggesting [12:05:11] devilesk: it doesn't look like a command [12:05:12] devilesk: sound like one |
| |
May 14 2008, 8:23 pm | Post #105 |
|
This block here is a perfect example of why after the majority was begging for latova, we were so sad to be handed v5. No offense IP but i believe the saying 'If it isnt broke, dont fix it.' applied here. The saying doesn't apply to novelty and innovation. StarCraft "ain't broke", why fix it by making mods or maps?[/quote] Latova started development with very early v5 code that I wrote. So technically v5 started a few months before latova did, but Latova has had way more development/testing than SEN has had. It's kind of fun to see some of the v5 stuff, I remember making a few minor things that are still in the v5 that slightly remind you of Latova. However the code process has drastically changed, the way v5 and Latova work are very different. IP went the way of PHP5 while I went the way of PHP4 backwards compatibility. |
||
| Money | May 15 2008, 12:27 am | Post #106 |
|
i has title
|
Wait, isn't v5 based on Invision Power Board? Or I am completely lost?
|
||
| ClansAreForGays | May 15 2008, 1:25 am | Post #108 |
|
This post has been a long time coming, the pervasive immaturity of the active user base, triviality of the topics of conversation, and the dearth of novel content has finally convinced me to let go. This community and that component of Maplantis that came here are but a shadow of the past, coasting on the innovation and creativity of a dynamic long dead. It is time for me to go, and I suspect those exceptions to the above rules will soon leave as well. I have no reservations about leaving them here because they know how to contact me, and someone invariably does anytime something interesting happens. Goodbye. This sucks. I could honestly say you were the smartest person here. I don't even know what kept you here so long. Your argument for or against something was always original and insightful. Unfortunately the returning counter argument was often lacking and repetitive. I could see you getting really frustrated when in the middle of a progressive debate, with say Rantent or Cheezus, Someone like Twitch hopes in and says "You gaiz, I think god is purpled." And then everyone jumps in to question the validity of this assigned color, including your 'opponent'. The endless debates we've had here became unfair as soon as you picked a side because then it was like getting Shaq to stand under your rim and goal tend anything that the other side could muster. So I guess it could be seen as a good thing with you gone. I wish we could pull another GF stunt here, but it probably won't happen. I was totally going to go on another rant on how Dapperdan should be NOT be moderating ANYTHING, but I noticed he finally lost what he never deserved, and that it would be like blaming Katrina on Mardi Gras. I still moderate 4 of the off-topic forums. It just doesn't show at the top of the forum. Good to know that I was moderating and you didn't even notice though. And it wasn't because there was a clear lack in moderation in those forums going on either. I've just been doing my job well and you have nothing to complain about. |
||
| Dapperdan | May 15 2008, 2:58 am | Post #109 |
|
God on Steroids
|
Stop trolling for christ's sake. You know what you say is BS.
|
||
![]() |
| DT_Battlekruser | May 15 2008, 3:03 am | Post #110 |
|
I paid eleven minerals for THIS?
|
It's kind of fun to see some of the v5 stuff, I remember making a few minor things that are still in the v5 that slightly remind you of Latova. However the code process has drastically changed, the way v5 and Latova work are very different. IP went the way of PHP5 while I went the way of PHP4 backwards compatibility. I think the big reason for being pro-Latova is not even so much feature-oriented, but simply because Latova is being regularly maintained
|
||
| (U)devilesk | May 15 2008, 3:09 am | Post #111 |
|
Classic
|
This post has been a long time coming, the pervasive immaturity of the active user base, triviality of the topics of conversation, and the dearth of novel content has finally convinced me to let go. This community and that component of Maplantis that came here are but a shadow of the past, coasting on the innovation and creativity of a dynamic long dead. It is time for me to go, and I suspect those exceptions to the above rules will soon leave as well. I have no reservations about leaving them here because they know how to contact me, and someone invariably does anytime something interesting happens. Goodbye. This sucks. I could honestly say you were the smartest person here. I don't even know what kept you here so long. Your argument for or against something was always original and insightful. Unfortunately the returning counter argument was often lacking and repetitive. I could see you getting really frustrated when in the middle of a progressive debate, with say Rantent or Cheezus, Someone like Twitch hopes in and says "You gaiz, I think god is purpled." And then everyone jumps in to question the validity of this assigned color, including your 'opponent'. The endless debates we've had here became unfair as soon as you picked a side because then it was like getting Shaq to stand under your rim and goal tend anything that the other side could muster. So I guess it could be seen as a good thing with you gone. I wish we could pull another GF stunt here, but it probably won't happen. I was totally going to go on another rant on how Dapperdan should be NOT be moderating ANYTHING, but I noticed he finally lost what he never deserved, and that it would be like blaming Katrina on Mardi Gras. I still moderate 4 of the off-topic forums. It just doesn't show at the top of the forum. Good to know that I was moderating and you didn't even notice though. And it wasn't because there was a clear lack in moderation in those forums going on either. I've just been doing my job well and you have nothing to complain about. |
||
![]() Re: Will Maphack be allowed in SC2? for LAST TIME MAPHACK IS NOT CHEAT. is ROCKET BOOSTER INTO SPACE CHEAT? ROCKET BOOSTER INTO SPACE MAKE SPACE TRAVEL EASIER BUT NOT CHEAT. THEREFORE, MAPHACK IS NOT CHEAT. WOW YOU PEOPLE ARE STUPIDS!!!! While playing Soldat: Bravo Team Member: staying two seconds at one place is not camping.. Alpha Team Member: ya.. and putting ur cock into a vag is not sex |
| |
May 15 2008, 4:38 am | Post #112 |
|
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
|
What?! How the fuck do you think I knew you were moderating in the first place. It just shows that it's such a terrible idea for you to be a mod that the site goes out of it's way to hide it. EDIT: I have fixed the cache issue. Moderators of individual forums will be properly listed at the top of their respective forums. Wait, isn't v5 based on Invision Power Board? Or I am completely lost? |
||
|
This post was edited 1 time, last edit by Mini Moose 2707: May 15 2008, 5:33 am.
![]() [11:59:05] devilesk: make some allusions to literature [11:59:48] devilesk: make it subtle [12:02:13] Moose: I don't need or want to be told how to make clues. [12:02:19] devilesk: im not telling [12:02:21] devilesk: i'm suggesting [12:05:11] devilesk: it doesn't look like a command [12:05:12] devilesk: sound like one |
| Vrael | May 19 2008, 5:38 am | Post #113 |
|
Title Pending.
|
In AntiSleep's original post, he failed to mention the great resource that SEN provides to mapmakers... lol
Epic Fail. 700-some topics in UMS Mapmaking Assistance right now... I'm sure this has been stated somewhere in the 6 pages of this topic, and I didn't read all 6, but I felt it worthy of reiterating. |
||
![]() |
| Sael | May 24 2008, 1:35 pm | Post #114 |
|
Why wasn't this topic written a few years ago? It would have been every bit as relevant then as it is now.
|
||
![]() |