Staredit Network > Forums > Media, Art, and Literature > Topic: The Dark Knight
The Dark Knight
Jul 19 2008, 9:46 pm
By: dumbducky
Pages: < 1 « 2 3 4 5 >
 

Jul 25 2008, 12:57 am Dem0n Post #61

ᕕ( ᐛ )ᕗ

I agree with everything you said devilisk. You people analyze movies way too much, and you suck at it. Esponeo, you are RETARDED. The reason Two Face went after Gordan's family was because Gordan's men were supposed to save Rachel but they were too late. He wanted to show Gordan what it feels like to tell his loved one that everything will be okay, even though he knows that it won't. Just like devilisk said, pay some attention to the movie. :<_<:




Jul 25 2008, 1:02 am Kaias Post #62



Quote from Esponeo
This topic by itself shows how laughably awful the movie was. No one can seem to agree on what happened. Half my friends are still insisting that Harvey Dent didn't die, that they saw him breathing.
You're friends are retarded. They'd like to think that he was still alive but he isn't and they haven't given any indication that he is. (They had a funeral that's pretty dang clear)

Quote
No one seems to agree on whether the Joker was captured.
That was the point

Quote
If I weren't so stupid I'd stop this post right there.
Well you really should have.

Quote
In the first movie, they made Batman out to be pretty cool. In this movie he spends way too much time in daylight, where he looks really dumb.
What, would you rather it be like Spiderman? Spiderman is cheesy, obnoxious and such a wiener.

Quote
Then you've got the Joker pretty much raping the shit out of Batman's mind.
No he didn't. Did you even pay attention to the movie at all? Batman didn't break at all.

Quote
The police already knew where the Joker and the hostages were.
Maroni tips the cops off, not Batman.

Quote
Moreover, they were in an unfinished building with absolutely no cellphones in it.
Actually the pulses are clearly coming from the fake hostages.

Quote
The Batman does not outsmart the Joker in some clever way and then proceed to have an epic final battle.
The whole thing was the epic battle and the whole city was their battlefield.

Quote
Oh I forgot, there's about 20 more minutes of movie after that where they horribly rape an iconic villain. You thought the ending to the Joker story was bad? You haven't seen anything yet. Remember how terrible the endings were to Spiderman 3 and Star Wars: Episode 3? Ever wonder what would happen if a script somehow combined those two into one ending? Oh my God, they actually did it!
You apparently don't understand the thesis of the movie. If you had half a brain you would realize how fitting the end was.

Spiderman 3 and SW3 don't have a thing on batman.

Quote
Harvey Dent has suddenly realized that the system is corrupt and he is going to take matters into his own hands, so he goes around killing all the people who apparently helped the Joker. Well, he killed all of them!
No he doesn't. Don't be a moron, he gives everyone a 50/50 chance because he realizes that chaos and chance is the only thing fair in the world, as it is completely unbiased.

Quote
With nothing else to do he decides to go kill Gordan's family for reasons totally different from his justification for killing all the people who actually betrayed him
No he wanted revenge, and wanted Gordon to go through what he did because he considered Gordon in fault for not keeping corruption out of his unit.

And he still holds to letting chance dictate life.

Quote
Only Two Face dies though.
Batman wasn't pushed out, he slipped from a lower height, he breaks a beam on the way down (which would lighten the land) and has armor

Quote
Oh wait, I forgot again.. there's yet another 10 minutes of film after that where the Batman QQs about how he isn't a bad person and we're giving a boring lecture on morals. It's really hard to listen to. I was pretty bored and wanted to leave at that point.
It wasn't that long and if you understood any other part of the movie then you would appreciate it. It completed the psychological spectrum to the movie in an excellent conclusion.

-----

Quote
Then towards the end he starts giving really ridiculous speeches, spoon feeding the audience the parallels between the Batman and the Joker. The script is just too terrible.
I can't even believe how incompetent you are about the whole thing. They weren't parallels either. The script was great, the only crappy lines belonged to the cop in the passenger's seat of the vehicle transporting Dent.

You want a terrible script, then go to Spiderman123

Quote
You know what I heard before seeing this movie? I heard that Two Face would be created as a villain in this movie and then show up in the next film.
Must be your idiot friends
Quote
That seemed like a really good idea to me. Instead they created him in this movie, rushed through his storyline, then killed him in a matter of 20 minutes. Why oh why didn't they just give us 20 more minutes of a movie about the Joker?
Just because it wasn't what you thought doesn't make it bad. He played his part, what more was he going to do?

Quote
Not to mention that the script is horribly racist. The Asian guy? His entire role in the film centers around him being good at math.
That doesn't make it racist. Of your whole post this is the most disgustingly presumptuous. The point of him being Chinese is that he couldn't possibly be extradited.



None.

Jul 25 2008, 1:04 am Kaias Post #63



P.S. I agree with devilesk.



None.

Jul 25 2008, 3:12 am Vrael Post #64



I thought The Dark Knight was pretty sweet.



None.

Jul 25 2008, 5:10 am DT_Battlekruser Post #65



I'm not going to read the long pages of controversy, but I thought it was an excellent film, one of the few films I have seen deserving of an 'A' rating (I tend to rate films on a letter scale).

'Enjoyable' is not a term I could ever apply to The Dark Knight, for it was a lot deeper and darker than that. Batman Begins is more rewatchable because it is simple and just a lot of fun to watch, but The Dark Knight has some aspects of frightening realism that really chill to the bone. People like the Joker really do exist, and Alfred provides a first-rate metaphor ('Did you catch him?' 'Yes.' 'How?' 'We burned the forest down.'). Heath Ledger gives a spellbinding performance as the Joker, easily convincing me of his psychotic nature and hearkening back to such masterpiece performances such as Peter Lorre as Hans Beckert in M (1931).

If the film had one weakness, Harvey Dent's fall into darkness was very poorly cataloged, but it could be seen as understandable nonetheless and at 2 hours and 32 minutes, critics were going to get antsy if it was much longer (I, on the other hand, don't mind long movies).

Oh and to dumbducky, make a point to see Batman Begins. It earns only an 'A-' in my book, but it is still one of the most awesome action movies of all time.




None.

Jul 25 2008, 5:11 am LoveLess Post #66

Let me show you how to hump without making love.

Movies are meant to be watched, not analyzed. If we did, it would be rather boring after a while and ruin any chance of wanting to see it again. And everyone says that if Ledger hadn't died, people wouldn't be glorifying his performance... He portrayed the Joker PERFECTLY in my own opinion and even kept that twist that this series has on the Batman lore (that being the whole more towards realism thing).

And I still feel that the movie should have ended for Two-Face right after the hospital had blown up.



None.

Jul 25 2008, 6:14 am The Great Yam Post #67



I liked it alot, but certain scenes didn't feel very well crafted, and it seemed at times to try and be subtle inbetween scenes like A GODDAMN TRACKER TRAILER FLIPPING OVER AND EXPLODING.

There were some moments where the action become alittle dulling (and deafening, the soundtrack was seeemingly heavy thudding on steel oil drums 80% of the movie) and there was just scene after scene of "WOW!". Still, it managed to really get you in the gut and twist you around, and it really did live up to a Darker Batman (I was actually alittle surprised).

Very good, not perfect. It was a very visceral movie, I don't know if it would hold up a second time through.

As for Ledger, I would've loved that performance if he had:
Not died.
Not been in an Batman film.
Not been wearing weird, bizarre make-up.

It was so sleazy, it basically defined the movie. It was like taking some of the nastiest parts of the Penguin in the second Batman (Tim Burton one) and merging it with Frank Miller's Batman, and giving it a little Hannibal Lector for good measure.

As for Bale, I liked his Batman alright, I didn't like his Bruce Wayne as much. I think they did a decent job getting Batman into the fore, but it was obvious there where parts when he just slipped into the background. He then became another series of walking fight scenes like all the other comic book movies. The villains always seemed to have much more style than Batman, and it's a difficult thing to work around. On that aspect, I think they did alright, but it was obvious they could've done better (for one thing, Batman successfully intimidates ... NO ONE THROUGHOUT THE FILM). It did bother me that no one reacted to a huge, powerful man dressed like a Bat landing on top of people's cars didn't freak ANYONE out, even if he was well-known.

Now, this film, overall, did a nice job on developed it's characters (I thought Dent was alittle weak, but like Bale he had some nice moments, particularly with Two-Face). The overall film worked, had some pacing issues, but worked, and was enjoyable, if gut-wrenching. Definitely not a Bat-movie for the Bat-kids. =P

Oh, but the 1989 film remains my favorite, its freakish cartoony nature has always won me over.



None.

Jul 25 2008, 7:09 am Demented Shaman Post #68



Quote from The Great Yam
I liked it alot, but certain scenes didn't feel very well crafted, and it seemed at times to try and be subtle inbetween scenes like A GODDAMN TRACKER TRAILER FLIPPING OVER AND EXPLODING.

There were some moments where the action become alittle dulling (and deafening, the soundtrack was seeemingly heavy thudding on steel oil drums 80% of the movie) and there was just scene after scene of "WOW!". Still, it managed to really get you in the gut and twist you around, and it really did live up to a Darker Batman (I was actually alittle surprised).

Very good, not perfect. It was a very visceral movie, I don't know if it would hold up a second time through.

As for Ledger, I would've loved that performance if he had:
Not died.
Not been in an Batman film.
Not been wearing weird, bizarre make-up.

It was so sleazy, it basically defined the movie. It was like taking some of the nastiest parts of the Penguin in the second Batman (Tim Burton one) and merging it with Frank Miller's Batman, and giving it a little Hannibal Lector for good measure.

As for Bale, I liked his Batman alright, I didn't like his Bruce Wayne as much. I think they did a decent job getting Batman into the fore, but it was obvious there where parts when he just slipped into the background. He then became another series of walking fight scenes like all the other comic book movies. The villains always seemed to have much more style than Batman, and it's a difficult thing to work around. On that aspect, I think they did alright, but it was obvious they could've done better (for one thing, Batman successfully intimidates ... NO ONE THROUGHOUT THE FILM). It did bother me that no one reacted to a huge, powerful man dressed like a Bat landing on top of people's cars didn't freak ANYONE out, even if he was well-known.

Now, this film, overall, did a nice job on developed it's characters (I thought Dent was alittle weak, but like Bale he had some nice moments, particularly with Two-Face). The overall film worked, had some pacing issues, but worked, and was enjoyable, if gut-wrenching. Definitely not a Bat-movie for the Bat-kids. =P

Oh, but the 1989 film remains my favorite, its freakish cartoony nature has always won me over.

Quote
Movies are meant to be watched, not analyzed.
QFT



None.

Jul 25 2008, 5:10 pm DT_Battlekruser Post #69



It's sort of a fact that China and Chinese investors hold trillions of dollars of US debt, both federal and private :P



None.

Jul 25 2008, 8:13 pm DevliN Post #70

OVERWATCH STATUS GO

I loved it, and I've actually gone back to see it 2 more times to try to catch some of the more subtle references they make (i.e. the short introduction of the Riddler, or Morgan Freeman remarking that the suit will be able to handle "cats"). I thought Batman Begins was awesome when I first saw it - though I did get completely burnt out by it after seeing it soooooooo many times. This is one of the rare times where I believe a sequel is a helluva lot better than the original.



\:devlin\: Currently Working On: \:devlin\:
My Overwatch addiction.

Jul 25 2008, 8:33 pm Demented Shaman Post #71



Quote from DevliN
I loved it, and I've actually gone back to see it 2 more times to try to catch some of the more subtle references they make (i.e. the short introduction of the Riddler, or Morgan Freeman remarking that the suit will be able to handle "cats"). I thought Batman Begins was awesome when I first saw it - though I did get completely burnt out by it after seeing it soooooooo many times. This is one of the rare times where I believe a sequel is a helluva lot better than the original.
Where's the riddler?



None.

Jul 25 2008, 10:50 pm The Great Yam Post #72



Quote from Devilesk
Movies are meant to be watched, not analyzed.
QFT
Forum topics on works of art are supposed to give a venue for opinions, not rampant fanboyism.

I actually liked the movie a lot.



None.

Jul 25 2008, 10:54 pm Demented Shaman Post #73



Quote from The Great Yam
Quote from Devilesk
Movies are meant to be watched, not analyzed.
QFT
Forum topics on works of art are supposed to give a venue for opinions, not rampant fanboyism.

I actually liked the movie a lot.
I don't see any rampant fanboyism. And too bad "fanboyism" is just someone's opinion.



None.

Jul 25 2008, 11:07 pm The Great Yam Post #74



I'm just saying it's alittle ridiculous that you expect everyone's opinion of this movie to be "OMFG IT WAS AWESUME AND HAD NO FLAWS AT ALL AND I WILL JUST SAY I LUVD DIS PART".

Well, whatever. It's not a big deal.



None.

Jul 26 2008, 12:09 am Demented Shaman Post #75



Quote from The Great Yam
I'm just saying it's alittle ridiculous that you expect everyone's opinion of this movie to be "OMFG IT WAS AWESUME AND HAD NO FLAWS AT ALL AND I WILL JUST SAY I LUVD DIS PART".
And it's ridiculous that you think that's what I expect everyone's opinion to be.



None.

Jul 26 2008, 2:04 am DevliN Post #76

OVERWATCH STATUS GO

Quote from name:devilesk
Quote from DevliN
I loved it, and I've actually gone back to see it 2 more times to try to catch some of the more subtle references they make (i.e. the short introduction of the Riddler, or Morgan Freeman remarking that the suit will be able to handle "cats"). I thought Batman Begins was awesome when I first saw it - though I did get completely burnt out by it after seeing it soooooooo many times. This is one of the rare times where I believe a sequel is a helluva lot better than the original.
Where's the riddler?
In the bank robbery scene. The "Bank Manager" with the shotgun (played by William Fichtner) had a name-tag that read "E. Nigma." Edward Nigma was the Riddler.

The Joker also puts a gas grenade in his mouth at the end of the scene that emits green smoke, perhaps another smaller hint.



\:devlin\: Currently Working On: \:devlin\:
My Overwatch addiction.

Jul 26 2008, 2:55 am Demented Shaman Post #77



Quote from DevliN
Quote from name:devilesk
Quote from DevliN
I loved it, and I've actually gone back to see it 2 more times to try to catch some of the more subtle references they make (i.e. the short introduction of the Riddler, or Morgan Freeman remarking that the suit will be able to handle "cats"). I thought Batman Begins was awesome when I first saw it - though I did get completely burnt out by it after seeing it soooooooo many times. This is one of the rare times where I believe a sequel is a helluva lot better than the original.
Where's the riddler?
In the bank robbery scene. The "Bank Manager" with the shotgun (played by William Fichtner) had a name-tag that read "E. Nigma." Edward Nigma was the Riddler.

The Joker also puts a gas grenade in his mouth at the end of the scene that emits green smoke, perhaps another smaller hint.
Oh wow I didn't see that at all. I just knew the guy was from Prison Break :P

It's odd that no one on the internet seems to have noticed it though. I tried to google more info on it but there's nothing about the Bank Manager's nametag. Nevermind, there's some discussion on William Fichtner's IMDB page about his role in the Dark Knight. People also think its a setup for the Riddler. Haven't seen the nametag yet though.

Post has been edited 2 time(s), last time on Jul 26 2008, 3:03 am by devilesk.



None.

Jul 26 2008, 2:58 am Doodan Post #78



Quote from DevliN
Quote from name:devilesk
Quote from DevliN
I loved it, and I've actually gone back to see it 2 more times to try to catch some of the more subtle references they make (i.e. the short introduction of the Riddler, or Morgan Freeman remarking that the suit will be able to handle "cats"). I thought Batman Begins was awesome when I first saw it - though I did get completely burnt out by it after seeing it soooooooo many times. This is one of the rare times where I believe a sequel is a helluva lot better than the original.
Where's the riddler?
In the bank robbery scene. The "Bank Manager" with the shotgun (played by William Fichtner) had a name-tag that read "E. Nigma." Edward Nigma was the Riddler.

The Joker also puts a gas grenade in his mouth at the end of the scene that emits green smoke, perhaps another smaller hint.
Heh, I thought it was strange that they cast a fairly well known actor in a 2 minute scene.



None.

Jul 26 2008, 3:07 am Demented Shaman Post #79



http://normgregory.com/2008/07/10/the-dark-knight-prologue/
It has the whole beginning scene. Can you point out where it shows the name tag?



None.

Jul 26 2008, 3:32 am dumbducky Post #80



A couple of my friends pointed out that they could have the Riddler be like a Joker copycat, like they did with the Batman imposters in the beginning.

I just watched the whole opening scene, and at the point when the manager is shooting at the robbers, you can clearly see his chest and tell that he isn't wearing any nametag.

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Jul 26 2008, 3:39 am by dumbducky.



tits

Options
Pages: < 1 « 2 3 4 5 >
  Back to forum
Please log in to reply to this topic or to report it.
Members in this topic: None.
[05:02 am]
Oh_Man -- whereas just "press X to get 50 health back" is pretty mindless
[05:02 am]
Oh_Man -- because it adds anotherr level of player decision-making where u dont wanna walk too far away from the medic or u lose healing value
[05:01 am]
Oh_Man -- initially I thought it was weird why is he still using the basic pre-EUD medic healing system, but it's actually genius
[03:04 am]
Ultraviolet -- Vrael
Vrael shouted: I almost had a heart attack just thinking about calculating all the offsets it would take to do that kind of stuff
With the modern EUD editors, I don't think they're calculating nearly as many offsets as you might imagine. Still some fancy ass work that I'm sure took a ton of effort
[12:51 am]
Oh_Man -- definitely EUD
[2024-5-05. : 9:35 pm]
Vrael -- I almost had a heart attack just thinking about calculating all the offsets it would take to do that kind of stuff
[2024-5-05. : 9:35 pm]
Vrael -- that is insane
[2024-5-05. : 9:35 pm]
Vrael -- damn is that all EUD effects?
[2024-5-04. : 10:53 pm]
Oh_Man -- https://youtu.be/MHOZptE-_-c are yall seeing this map? it's insane
[2024-5-04. : 1:05 am]
Vrael -- I won't stand for people going around saying things like im not a total madman
Please log in to shout.


Members Online: Roy