@TiKels: Or we trust in Kaias' ability to pick competent judges. He seems to be doing a good job so far.

However you present some interesting aspects every judge should keep in mind.

Yayy finally someone replied to my ideas. Thanks!

Kaias, is there a way you could post a list of current judges?... i wanted to know who is on it. (wink wink)

@Nude (lulz): They were just ideas, they don't have to be used and I'm not saying there's anything wrong with the way things are going at the moment. They are just thought provoking comments. And thanks for the compliment, "...you present some interesting aspects every judge should keep in mind."

Necropolis probably won't be done in time, unexpected RL things slowed me down. I'll still release, just PROBABLY not for the contest.

Oh, by the way, THREE MORE DAYS

Also, I need more judges, a couple had to resign owed to the extension. Because it is so soon, I'm going to throw out the 'you can't judge if you are submitting' rule and just make it so they judges can't judge their own map.

EDIT:
Current Line-up:

• NudeRaider
  
• Psionic_Storm
  
• CecilSunkure
  

I'll judge.

Quote from MC²TassadarZeratul

I'll judge.

Sure.

I thought cecil had his lost souls rpg or whatever?

Quote from samsizzle

I thought cecil had his lost souls rpg or whatever?

Quote from Kaias

I'm going to throw out the 'you can't judge if you are submitting' rule and just make it so they judges can't judge their own map.

Hawt. Taylor swift makes maps.

Almost done. Damn terrain. And a cool nifty feature. From what I can tell so far, judging might not take that long.

I thought I remember you saying that the Judges will be 'everyone' ...

I'm not gonna bother trying to find that post :\ .. but I feel a poll should still be held for this.

Quote from Kaias

Evaluation
Maps will not be judged by any set rubric, nor by any judges, but rather by the community. The mineral reward will be distributed among the seven most reputable submissions. Distribution percentages will be determined when the time comes. All exceptional entries will receive a minimum of 100 minerals.

Incidentally, I'd like to be a judge in this too. I'm not submitting anything :C

EDIT: I agree w/ tikels about there being no standards... perhaps you (Kaias) or all purposed judges (or some random folks with brilliant ideas) can come up with one

EDIT²: Yeah.. it wasn't hard to find the quote.. as it was stated in the first post a year ago... maybe you want to clear things up a bit, kaias... Do you REALLY want to have judges? If so, it'd be better to have a standard "rubric" or system, as it becomes a few people judging a large quantity of maps. If it was community polls, then there is no need (or not much need) of a system....

I wanna be judge D:
I will not f* be biaised over terrain D:<

<Rantent enters the RPG Contest>

You know... unless the name was changed, there are two Lost Souls rpgs being entered into this contest. If I am not mistaken, Ultimoo and Cecilsunkure are both submitting one.
Also...
... Judge me up Scotty! </lamejoke>
(To remove any sort of confusion, that was my request to be a judge)

I'll judge if it's absolutely necessary... I wish I had the endurance you all have to map for a whole year.

Quote from LoveLess!

I'll judge if it's absolutely necessary... I wish I had the endurance you all have to map for a whole year.

Most of us didn't actually map for a whole year.

Quote from samsizzle

Quote from LoveLess!

I'll judge if it's absolutely necessary... I wish I had the endurance you all have to map for a whole year.

Most of us didn't actually map for a whole year.

2 did

My map is released. X

Quote from xYoshix

My map is released. X

Oh hell yes . Time to play.

I'd like to judge too if possible.. lots of free time lately...

I'm wondering how many other people managed to get their map finished.

Quote from xYoshix

I'm wondering how many other people managed to get their map finished.

I managed to finish mine but some updated version might come later. I was hoping to get an updated version this week before the deadline but doesn't look like it. Version B is pretty bug free anyway. So yeah it was fun