[skip all navigation]

Magazine Name, ROUND 2!, Observer vs. Untiltled Scenario

Pages: 1 2 3 >
Creator: ClansAreForGays
Time: Jun 30 2009, 6:11 pm

Polls

Collapse
#1 :: What should the zine be called?

What should the zine be called?
The Observer (and all its variations)
Untitled Scenario
   
Minimum answers: 1 ~ Maximum answers: 1

Post #2     ClansAreForGays Jun 30 2009, 6:11 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
The opinion seems to be split between some variation of The Observer and Untitled Scenario. SENzine was also a popular choice, but doesn't have any sort of ring to it. I find these 2 choices have very distinct strengths and weaknesses. They are both worthy of use and would be more than willing to use either.

The Observer
Pros:
Happens to be a SC unit.
Flexible enough to include SEN in the name.
Comes with a mascot.
More professional sounding.

Cons:
Not as UMS related
Not the most fitting to our theme. I'd imagine this would be more sensible for a site like TeamLiquid's that gets exclusives, hear-it-here-first's, and Blizzard leaks.
*Copyright worries here are unfounded. It should not be considered a con.

Untitled Scenario
Pros:
Most closely matches the theme of the zine.
Almost an inside joke that any SC mapper (target audience) gets.
Identifies our very specific niche which we excel in.

Cons:
Not as professional sounding.
Does not explicitly mention the Staredit Network.
Some people might not get it.

If The Observer wins, expect another poll on which variation.

Top

Post #3     Excalibur Jun 30 2009, 6:13 pm

[Avatar]
Staredit.net Global Moderator
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Further con for untitled scenario: Makes it look like we're only mapping, and modding should be included too.

Voted Observer.

-{ Diplomacy: Empires | Blog | Melee QC & Resources }-
"You must be careful because we are dealing with people here, not machines or code. If you make a mistake or want to do something differently when you're coding, you change it, run it again and the computer does not know the difference. The same ease of reversibility does not apply to the user, or human affairs in general. While we all empathize with a desire for second chances sometimes, the fact that something can be undone does not make it a good idea - there will be consequences." -Moose
Top

Post #4     lil-Inferno Jun 30 2009, 6:17 pm

[Avatar]
The carousal does not inaugurate pending my admission.
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Instead of Untitled Scenario, it should be Untitled SENario :) .

Top

Post #5     Biophysicist Jun 30 2009, 6:18 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
That sounds really unprofessional. Makes it look like we can't spell.

Top

Post #6     LoveLess Jun 30 2009, 6:19 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Voted Observer, it just fits in my opinion. It kind of just rolls off the tongue. The Mascot Pro makes me think of an observer made in an emoticon fashion.

Top

Post #7     Kaias Jun 30 2009, 6:30 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
SEN Observer. Untitled Scenario just sounds too plain.

Top

Post #8     BlueWolf Jun 30 2009, 6:49 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
The Observer. Nice and simple. When the mascot of the observer is created, just make him look like he is "edited."

Top

Post #9     JaFF Jun 30 2009, 7:17 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Elite
The Observer sounds much more stylish and professional. And it fits the theme.

Top

Post #10     ClansAreForGays Jun 30 2009, 7:21 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Quote from JaFF
The Observer sounds much more stylish and professional. And it fits the theme.
I'd say it only fits the theme that this is about SC. I'd like to think that while is doesn't exclude anything from its startcraft discussion, it still has a specialty or niche. In just general SC or SC2 discussion we can't hold a candle to TL, but in map making/modding we have 'the high ground'

Top

Post #11     Hug A Zergling Jun 30 2009, 7:34 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
I like the observer, but it sounds more like a Newspaper then an eZine. I voted Untitled Scenario, thought I like both.

Top

Post #12     DT_Battlekruser Jun 30 2009, 8:05 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Elite
The Observer. No comparison.

"Three can keep a secret, if two are dead." -Benjamin Franklin

"Had, having, and in quest to have, extreme;
A bliss in proof, and proved, a very woe;
Before, a joy proposed; behind, a dream.
All this the world well knows; yet none knows well
To shun the heaven that leads men to this hell."
-William Shakespeare
Top

Post #13     JaFF Jun 30 2009, 10:35 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Elite
Quote from ClansAreForGays
Quote from JaFF
The Observer sounds much more stylish and professional. And it fits the theme.
I'd say it only fits the theme that this is about SC. I'd like to think that while is doesn't exclude anything from its startcraft discussion, it still has a specialty or niche. In just general SC or SC2 discussion we can't hold a candle to TL, but in map making/modding we have 'the high ground'
Though I agree with you, I don't think that justification is enough to throw away such an awesome name in all other respects.

Top

Post #14     FaZ- Jul 1 2009, 5:11 am

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
I voted Untitled Scenario.

The Observer sounds so plain, I feel like I've seen that as the title of a half-dozen fictional newspapers (Spiderman maybe?).

We don't really tell anyone anything about the zine with "The Observer," and we don't cater to our audience with it. As CAFG pointed out, about the only thing that we might contest with TL (or other sites) in is melee mapmaking discussion. Everything else that we'll publish on we're essentially competitionless, and we should promote that uniqueness rather than the giving a title that resembles what EVERYONE does.

The pun is semi-clever, but it's far too bland to me.

Top

Post #15     ClansAreForGays Jul 1 2009, 5:36 am

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Quote
As CAFG pointed out, about the only thing that we might contest with TL (or other sites) in is melee mapmaking discussion.
I think you meant to say UMS map making. We even hold glitter to http://www.panschk.de/mappage/newsscript/viewnews.php

Top

Post #16     Pyro682 Jul 1 2009, 5:52 am

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Ok. Gotta say-

The Observer Pwns. 'Nuff Said.

Top

Post #17     [Riney]:] Jul 1 2009, 4:06 pm

[Avatar]
Sunglasses throwing attack! >;O
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
But but guys, what if someone else makes a magazine/newsthingie called the Missle Turret.

We'd be doomed :O

(user posted image)
Click the picture for DM's newest zombie adventure ;D
Im Kate Lockwell mother fuckers xD
Top

Post #18     Pyro682 Jul 1 2009, 4:18 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Dude, No. Remember the Glitch where if you keep moving the observer until it's over the Missile Turret, like in the "Can you do 25 tricks" map?
We pwn Missile Turrets.

Top

Post #19     BlueWolf Jul 1 2009, 7:54 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Are there any good spell names? Like Psionic Storm? I'm only trying to think of a different name, since The Observer is already taken irl.

Top

Post #20     DevliN Jul 1 2009, 8:28 pm

[Avatar]
ADMIN STATUS GO
offlinecontact
Rank: Administrator
Quote from Mp)BluEditor
Are there any good spell names? Like Psionic Storm? I'm only trying to think of a different name, since The Observer is already taken irl.
Which is why we're calling it "The Staredit Network Observer," not just "The Observer."

CURRENTLY WORKING ON:
Shadowlands | Demonic: Urban Apocalypse
TERRAN 2259 | Unnamed Fight Map | Recon
Top

Post #21     Mini Moose 2707 Jul 1 2009, 10:32 pm

[Avatar]
onlinecontact
Rank: Administrator
Quote from Mp)BluEditor
Are there any good spell names? Like Psionic Storm? I'm only trying to think of a different name, since The Observer is already taken irl.
None that really match up with generic newspaper or magazine names. I wasn't even thinking about the StarCraft unit when I suggested it.

A Man said to the universe:
"Sir, I exist."
"However," replied the universe,
"The fact has not created in me
A sense of obligation."
- Stephen Crane
Top
0 members in this topic (italic members are currently writing a reply): None
+ 0 guest(s)


[10:05 pm]
Raccoon -- b/c when people complain they say "OMG THAT IS SO CHEAP NERF IT!" and not "Based on my hypothetical simulations played out through my mind, I concede that it would be for the better of all to buff the underdog."
[10:03 pm]
Taylor Swift -- I think it would have been smarter to buff zerg rather than nerf reaper build times, but Blizzard likes balancing with nerfs rather than buffs. :P
[10:01 pm]
Symmetry -- should cost 86 minerals and take 2 days to build
[10:01 pm]
Symmetry -- I think scvs are op
[09:59 pm]
CecilSunkure -- Yeah, that's why it's being nerfed.
[09:58 pm]
Taylor Swift -- even if you don't, you don't deny how effective the build is against zerg?
[09:56 pm]
Taylor Swift -- terran almost always opens with 5 rax reaper, and the zerg can barely ever do anything about it in TvZ.
Please log in to shout.