I've read the debate, and akar is being very open-minded about his opponent's(everyone) counter-arguements, and is trying to argue in a fresh way. You are the only person here trying to express your own thoughts, instead of a 'consensus'.
Everyone else is attacking like a stuckup dick. Do you people know your words would have more impact of you put yourself on the same level as the person you are talking to? When you give short, smart-ass retorts to someone's paragraphs of thoughts and views, people ussually hit the 'off' button and then its all over. Atleast try to be thought provoking in your responses.
You see akar, there are 2 ways people typically become aethiests:
1) The individual just doesn't have faith. They don't hate god, or became what they are due to a horrible religious experience. They just don't feel this 'ultimate love' that people talk about. I like to believe I fall into this category. We can hae strong relationships with people of faith because we are secure in ours, or lack there of. I shouldn't care if someone is preaching at me when I know it won't change the way I feel. I have nothing to fear. And if it does, it still doesn't harm me in any way.
2) Then there are ugly people. I mean literally ugly people. People that are very unattractive and unliked. I swear to god every poor fat kid, or acne ridden loser is a smug aethiest. They hate the god that they at the same time somehow don't believe in, and they hate the world. The thought of people loving life, finding purpose, and creditting a greater power disgust them. They have been dealt horrible hands. The reason they so zealously argue with believers is because, well think about this:
Jimmy is an unpopluar ugly boy w/o a girlfriend.
Brad has a very hot g/f, and is taller, and more handsome than Jimmy. He also happens to go to church, and is filled with faith and thanks god for everything he has.
Jimmy tells Brad there is no god, and that his worship is all pretend.
Jimmy then shows Brad all the scientific evidence he found on the internet, showing step by step how his life is a lie, and won't go to heaven. Brad is shaken.
Suddenly, life is fair again.
Ofcourse this scenario never happens, but logically it should. So they keep chasing this impossible dream fro the classroom to the internet.
I think this makes up a good deal of our blasphemous population.
I just wish akar would stop talking about how science=/=religion but science+religion=truth