Crap. That third one is probably mine. I made it in about an hour.

EDIT: But there are only three prizes and three maps... (YAY! )

I'm a freaking psychic.

Well, I don't see the need to make a new topic for the ratings, so, here they are:

FIRST PLACE:

Razorsnails' Grogv0.1.scm

lolwut. Okay, this was pretty fun and I really liked the terrain. At first, I was really confused as it seemed to be a lot coming at me in the first tutorial. I did get the hang of it though. However... it did get a bit repetitive.

Theme: 10/10
lol, yessir.

Professionalism: 15/15
Some words, such as, "till" broke the professionalism of the map. However! It did appeal to me and it would appeal to b.net players. Considering that b.netters are 100% of the market, I would say that this is very professional in that consideration. Good job.

Fun: 10/15
Hmm... The repetiveness did get to me, but then I started screwing around and it was pretty fun. The distilling process needs to be refined though. For the control panel, maybe use the starport instead.

Originality: 10/10
This was a totally new concept that seemed to me like an RPG meets Defense meets the SIMS. I loved it.

45/50 == 90%


SECOND PLACE:

Heegu's Zinglon_ale.scx

A very nicely disguised defense map. I liked the 3x3 unit build up idea, yet it felt slow paced and gameplay was fairly quick.

Theme: 10/10
You fight for a beer keg -- it appears to fit the theme.

Professionalism: 12/15
The map seems fairly professional. I found no glitches excpe that the bottom team has a slight advantage for some odd reason (they will eventually make it to my base on their own if I do nothing during the game).

Fun: 10/15
I might play this once and a while, but I don't think it will become a favorite. I was a little too slow paced and the bases were a little too close together for lengthy gameplay.

Originality: 9/10
I really liked this map's originality. I felt like I was playing a new map that didn't overly copy a basic b.net map. Good job.

41/50 == 82%


THIRD PLACE:

Stickynote's Alcohol Island

Theme: 5/10
You drink beer to run faster. Thats pretty much it. I didn't see really any point to this.

Professionalism: 7/15
It didn't seem very complete and I felt like it was lacking.

Fun: 3/15
I'm sorry, but I would not play this map again. It seemed very boring.

Originality: 7/10
This seems mainly like a tag map/survivial map -- fairly original.

22/50 == 44%

How many maps were actually submitted?

Moar contest plz.

HELL YES! lol!! *bow*. totally didn't know what to expect, but I definitely worked my ass off on that thing. A_of-s_t, I'm gonna need to get more feedback from you soon.

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Jul 3 2008, 7:58 am by razorsnail.

Congratulations razorsnail!

Probably four, with Falkoner.


Clokr_ and I were far too busy to even work on it. But hey, my concept map for the contest was <3

I ended up not submitting my map, as it was unfinished, although looking at that last map, I know it could have at least beaten that... Even being 1/3rd done It was a pretty cool map, I think I will finish it, I also think I made add another game style where you control all the spawn and such in the map, because it's all variable, so I can change a death count and modify all sorts of variables, such as which docks are active, how many transport ships each large ship at the docks have, what units the transport ships drop off, how fast they drop off, how fast the defenses of the players repair, and many other variables, I think I'll go ahead and finish it anyway, as it was a very neat idea.

w00t! 3rd place by default! I only made a map because I felt that I should submit something, even though it was a real piece of shit. I'm more interested in a current project.

I shall participate.

It's already over.

I believe my concept map alone will be ranked number one.

Seriously, you get the feeling of under the influence of alcohol.

Submit it. I may give you a notewothy prize >.>

Where can we download these maps?

Whenever they upload them -- most were sent to me via links.

Post the links?

To remind you, it is only a concept map. I'll have to show it to you through Battle Net.

You mean something like shaking the screen?

I'll release Grog soon.