Hold on, why is this still going? afaik there's currently 5 mafia and 4 townies. One townie is an elder. That's 5 votes to 5 votes. Mafia wins by default, right?

Maybe Roy had hope for us. Either way, you wont kill anyone tonight, and tomorrow you will lynch the Elder. This should be over.

Roy, why did you start with 8 Mafia when we had 22 players?

This is pretty stupid now. It's just a stalemate... End it Roy, mafia won.
Mafia got pretty lucky with the bomb killing bunches of townies though, you have to take in that fact before you say mafia were over powered.

I really doubt Roy started with 8 mafias....

8 Mafia to 14 Townies isn't a great ratio.

EDIT:
Norm, we have 6 Mafia left and killed 2. He started with 8.

Are you a mafia that can verify this? Or just a speculating townie?

1-to-1 means there is literally 1 Mafia and 1 Townie remaining. It's not meant to be a ratio.

The rule is clear. As soon as the total number of Mafia votes outnumber the total voting capability of the Town, the game ends. Last vote, there were 6 Mafia votes versus a voting capability of 6. That's not sufficient.


Not necessarily.


It wasn't luck, the Vigilante was purposely sabotaging the Town. I agree that the balance was likely sufficient, if the Vigilante had been trying to help the Town (or simply not been active at all) then the Town would have won.

You have to remember that only 3 of the Mafia could attack, and the Bomb, Bodyguard, and Vigilante can even up those numbers real quick. Only two of those three roles were playing properly this game, unfortunately.

Imago was Godfather. General was a Hitman. All 6 who voted for LoTu)S have to be Mafia.

I'm not quite sure how it's even possible for town to win.

:S So not really 100% true assertions. This just makes it all the more interesting to have the roles revealed at the end.

I'm willing to bet anything that I am right. All 6 are Mafia. You'll see.

I'm not quite sure why 6 mafia votes vs 6 townie votes should not result in a mafia win, whereas you claim 1 mafia vote vs. 2 townie votes should.

Of course it would end the game, the Townies would lynch the Mafia How did I say that would be a Mafia win?

1 non-hitman mafia vs. 1 elder at the end of a day. That is a 1-to-1 case, yet the rules stipulate that mafia wins even though the elder can clearly outvote the mafia on the following day.

Keep in mind that if the mafia kill anyone at night its their victory

Even if there were a lot of mafia, they only could kill 3 people per night.

That would be 1-to-2. It specifically says "maximum vote capability."

It's a good thing we've got our Elder covered, then.

Whatever. The point stands that this game has already been won by Mafia.

Context is your friend.


Nope, not yet