Staredit Network > Forums > Staredit Network > Topic: being able to comment on reviews
being able to comment on reviews
Aug 22 2008, 5:38 pm
By: SiberianTiger  

Aug 22 2008, 5:38 pm SiberianTiger Post #1

we should be able to criticize reviews as well

all of the reviews that i read are 9.9/10 9.5/10, etc. if i know something wrong about a review i should be able to comment on it

comments also put pressure on the authors of reviews to be more careful about what they're saying


Aug 22 2008, 7:30 pm Moose Post #2

Perhaps you should consider simply writing your own reviews.

Aug 22 2008, 9:21 pm JamaL Post #3

Quote from name:
Perhaps you should consider simply writing your own reviews.

A simple half-solution, but what he is proposing is an (easily-performed?) improvement to the review system.

The question is of course, then: would it be used enough? Probably not.


Aug 22 2008, 11:36 pm Symmetry Post #4

Dungeon Master

Maybe a plus/minus system like on youtube, but comments on reviews is taking it a little too far...

:voy: :jaff: :voy: :jaff:

Aug 23 2008, 12:48 am Doodan Post #5

Could I review your review of my review?


Aug 23 2008, 12:49 am Hercanic Post #6

STF mod creator, admin, staff

Some "reviews" actually belong in the comment section.

I think the comment/review sections should be connected to the forum, for ease of seeing when new messages are posted and to facilitate moderation.

Aug 24 2008, 5:49 am FoxWolf1 Post #7

It would be nice to be able to respond somehow to points brought up in reviews...a new "review" as a reply wouldn't be appropriate, but posting in "Comments" would put your reply in the stream of the comments-section discussion and not connect it to the review.


Sep 9 2008, 2:54 pm Hercanic Post #8

STF mod creator, admin, staff

Review comments? Maybe if reviews existed as forum posts, and the review format on the file's page could have a Comments (x) link next to the title.

  Back to forum
Please log in to reply to this topic or to report it.
Members in this topic: None.
[09:04 pm]
RIVE -- Big facts
[08:23 pm]
Vrael -- just don't use the search box
[08:23 pm]
Vrael -- SEN is as watertight as a frog's butt
[07:45 pm]
Suicidal Insanity -- SEN? Secure? lawl never thought I'd see that
[06:32 pm]
MTiger156 -- Been playing around with the API's i was able to dig up in the javascript. Seems there's more to it than just forcing parameter values. Security pretty tight up in here.
[05:57 pm]
NudeRaider -- tbh thats the most likely way people got told it
[03:43 pm]
Suicidal Insanity -- Why would the FTP password be in the SQL DB? Unless somebody sent it via PM :X
[03:23 pm]
Vrael -- pearfishing*
[03:23 pm]
Vrael -- spearphishing**
[03:23 pm]
Vrael -- I accept the challenge, I will begin by discovering Moose's email and spearphising him and using social media tactics to learn about the mods lives, then I will use that leverage to hold the site ransom until they yield the password!
Please log in to shout.

Members Online: Roy