|
This movie was awful.
SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS The ridiculously complex plots laid out are absurd. Plot twist after plot twist gradually becomes insulting to the viewer. The Joker was not "always a step ahead" as a villain might be in quality film. Instead he was ten steps ahead from the very beginning, having God-like knowledge of all events that would occur. Even worse is that the last step in his initial plan involves a man with a bomb in his stomach. That's just stupid. Having the bomb inside yourself does not magically make the receiver immune to metal detectors. Having a giant protrusion on your stomach also seems like something the guards would have noticed before they put these guys in a cell. On a lesser note, the Joker's speech that he "doesn't plan anything" is silly. He has clearly planned a lot. It doesn't even make sense for him to be lying in that speech. It doesn't add anything. The Joker's character is already well established and it had already been made quite clear that he was a liar. By the end of the movie there are tons of plot lines all fighting for screen time. None of them are satisfactorily closed. The Joker, despite having had clairvoyance enough to know the plot of the three quarters of the movie in advance, stands around like an idiot at the end and gets captured. Batman did absolutely nothing to defeat the Joker. He didn't outsmart him, he did not use his wiles to win. After the Joker is caught, there is not even any indication that he has been incarcerated. The last scene we see him in is where he is hanging off a building. What happens to him? It isn't even that things aren't resolved, they are. The problem is that the various plots are resolved sloppily and in the most unsatisfying way possible. Okay, so Harvey Dent is remembered a hero. Does that mean the mob bosses he attempted to arrest will in fact go to jail? The movie doesn't say. The more I think about this movie the more disgusted I am by how bad it is. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
LOL! DTBK actually paid for this!
|
Yeah, he probably got dropped on purpose when he was a child.
I'm no cartoon fan but I think you pretty much just told who the joker is, so what's wrong? Also, a joker is someone who fools people and plays pranks on them, to do that you must be steps ahead, duh. Of course he was lying, he's the joker, again, duh. Anyway, I think it was an actually pretty good movie, and note that I'm not a huge fan of heavily commercial movies but anyway. I felt that it was missing a "something" where, like Esponeo said, the villain died or went to prision or anything at all. I kinda was expecting it to happen, and I know a lot of people were, for the joker to die because of Ledger's controversial death. But then again it was clear enough because batman said that he was going to spend the rest of his life in a hospital for mentally ill people and well, the SWAT team caught him in the end. Also one point less that it was is when they start getting all clever and act like philosophists, they just confused me several parts at some points and actually forced me to read the subtitles But overall I liked this movie. The Joker is perfectly achieved, as I thought it would be, but overall it has nothing extraordinarie. |
|
The whole point of a plot twist is to surprise the viewer. When that very same plot twist is rendered completely inert by another plot twist minutes later, it is annoying and insulting.
The Joker is not a super intelligent genius and he is not a God. Right. But within the context of the movie it doesn't even make any sense for that conversation to happen. It only makes sense to the viewer, which is a sort of indirect way of breaking the fourth wall. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
President Elect
|
No the point of a plot twist isn't to surprise the viewer. What made you a film expert? Are you a director? Do you write scripts? Do you know what was going on in their minds? No.
When that very same plot twist is rendered completely inert by another plot twist minutes later, it is annoying and insulting. I'm no cartoon fan but I think you pretty much just told who the joker is, so what's wrong? Of course he was lying, he's the joker, again, duh. Also, I'd like to cite this topic as showing how foolish Esponeo has proven himself to be. Esponeo It's clear that no one should be intimidated by Esponeo's attempt to seem superior or an authority. Esponeo isn't always right, in fact, he's wrong most of the time. He just needs to be confronted by someone who isn't fooled by his tricks and is persistent enough to fight his attacks. Just like Batman fighting the Joker. This post was edited 1 time, last edit by devilesk: Jul 20 2008, 6:48 am.
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
I am the adversary.
|
The movie was great, 10/10.
Esponeo you both can't see and over examine the obvious parts of the movie. Joker is planning things as he goes, he's one step ahead not 10. All your 'unanswered questions' are answered, you just refuse to see them. EDIT: Also for some reason The Dark Knight is #1 in IMDB. Crazy as it sounds I think it might stay in the top 10. http://www.imdb.com/chart/top?tt0468569 ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
President Elect
|
The movie was great, 10/10. Esponeo you both can't see and over examine the obvious parts of the movie. Joker is planning things as he goes, he's one step ahead not 10. All your 'unanswered questions' are answered, you just refuse to see them. EDIT: Also for some reason The Dark Knight is #1 in IMDB. Crazy as it sounds I think it might stay in the top 10. http://www.imdb.com/chart/top?tt0468569 Also, compare the vote counts. It's still VERY low, and I'm sure its just the fanboys out there rating it an automatic 10/10. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
Der Metzgermeister
|
I plan on seeing this movie very soon. I also loved Batman Begins, it was great.
Esponeo - There is a difference between planning events and having a plan. He just wants to create chaos, the events are not connected to be a super-crime-boss or anything, just to create chaos. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() I believe in:
|
|
I pwn nubs like you.
|
This movie was awful. SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS The ridiculously complex plots laid out are absurd. Plot twist after plot twist gradually becomes insulting to the viewer. The Joker was not "always a step ahead" as a villain might be in quality film. Instead he was ten steps ahead from the very beginning, having God-like knowledge of all events that would occur. Even worse is that the last step in his initial plan involves a man with a bomb in his stomach. That's just stupid. Having the bomb inside yourself does not magically make the receiver immune to metal detectors. Having a giant protrusion on your stomach also seems like something the guards would have noticed before they put these guys in a cell. On a lesser note, the Joker's speech that he "doesn't plan anything" is silly. He has clearly planned a lot. It doesn't even make sense for him to be lying in that speech. It doesn't add anything. The Joker's character is already well established and it had already been made quite clear that he was a liar. By the end of the movie there are tons of plot lines all fighting for screen time. None of them are satisfactorily closed. The Joker, despite having had clairvoyance enough to know the plot of the three quarters of the movie in advance, stands around like an idiot at the end and gets captured. Batman did absolutely nothing to defeat the Joker. He didn't outsmart him, he did not use his wiles to win. After the Joker is caught, there is not even any indication that he has been incarcerated. The last scene we see him in is where he is hanging off a building. What happens to him? It isn't even that things aren't resolved, they are. The problem is that the various plots are resolved sloppily and in the most unsatisfying way possible. Okay, so Harvey Dent is remembered a hero. Does that mean the mob bosses he attempted to arrest will in fact go to jail? The movie doesn't say. The more I think about this movie the more disgusted I am by how bad it is. No... you just... fail... Batman did do things to catch the Joker. Are you retarded? He used his technology to find him, then he used his fighting skills to get the Joker to fall out of the building. And the guards didn't notice the phone in the guy's stomach. Uh, maybe they didn't look at his stomach? And the Joker was always a step ahead. He got out of the police and Batman's clutches every time until the end of the movie. Of course Batman's not going to kill the Joker after he catches him. If you remember in Batman Begins, right before the train is about to crash, Batman says to Ras Al Gul (however you spell it), "I'm not going to kill you, but I don't have to save you." You obviously don't know what you're talking about. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Clan Oo FTW!!
![]() |
|
This film takes some risks that are pretty brave for a summer blockbuster, and those are worth praise I give the movie a 4.5/5 and it's completely due to the joker. It should have actually been called The Joker. The Dark Knight was deceptive. I was expecting a dark badass batman with more of an attitude of "the ends justify the means" What I got was a pussy. I really thought the movie should have just ended after joker blew up the hospital. This post was edited 1 time, last edit by ClansAreForGays: Jul 20 2008, 7:14 pm.
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Gerard DuGalle: "You vastly underestimate me, my dear."
Infested Kerrigan: "I don't think so, Admiral. You see, at this point... I'm pretty much the Queen Bitch of the Universe. And not all of your little soldiers or space ships will stand in my way again." |
|
I was trying not to post any spoilers in my review. ;p
SPOILER ALERT!!! -They kill of the lead female character. That almost never happens, and I'm proud of them for doing it. -It calls the nature of morality into question, rather than saying "Here's the good guys and here's the bad guys" in the first 10 minutes and then making you wait 90 minutes for the inevitable final battle where the good guys win. -Numerous things aren't clearly resolved - just like in life. I hate how movies try to tie up every loose end, unless they're planning a sequel (and this film is likely planning one, but many things were left so unclear that you have no idea what the next installment might be like). -I was kind of impressed with Gordon's "death", but then they brought him back. I'm not sure what to think of that one, but meh, it wasn't bad. And I like how the characters weren't restricted to cliche behavior only. I dunno, I guess I've just seen so much garbage that I'm happy when a movie has half a brain and knows that its audience does too. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Haikus are easy
But sometimes they don't make sense Refridgerator |