So you have played 3 days in a row your favourite SMC III mod... So you have seen the work that was done.... It's time to crush them! Refering to [url=http://www.staredit.net/topic/2146/0/]this topic[/url] the polls are now open for public. So, here's the deal: - You must rate 1 out of 5 being 1 the lowest possible score and 5 the highest. Jokes like OMG I GIVE IT A 6 will result in the corban vision automatic script setting the rating as 1, not 5, not the closet number to anything, 1. - You can change your rating (to other mods) whenever you wish before the poll closes. - The poll will close in.. say... hmm.. sunday? Sure, sunday sounds good. I'll ask you to play the mod before rating it, yes a any random person can create an account and vote like a very mean person and it will be taken into consideration, of course, so, play the mods, please :P Try to be as critical as possible, of course this poll is more for like "OMG ITS VOY SO I GIVE IT A 5" and it will still be valid but try to be critical :P The mods you are rating are: [quote]A_of_s_t, with his mod Critters vs Hunters to be found under the following link: [url=http://www.staredit.net/topic/3253/]Official Topic for CvH by Author[/url] Killer_Kow & O)FaRTy1billion[MM], with their mod Etu Nimstal to be found under the following link: [url=http://www.staredit.net/topic/3414/]Official Topic for EN by one Author[/url] Killer_Kow, with his last minute jokes and not to be considered for prizes but to be rated as well as others: [url=http://www.staredit.net/?attachment=1198]Hello, Desktop[/url], [url=http://www.staredit.net/?attachment=1199]no ESCAPE[/url], [url=http://www.staredit.net/?attachment=1200]smC_JOKE_ENTRY[/url]. Phobos[MM] & Polaris[MM] & Eternus & Voyager, with their mod Masters of Holocaust v1.1 to be found under the following link, [url=http://www.staredit.net/topic/2848/]Official Topic for MoH 1.1 by one Author[/url] bajadulce & poiuy_qwert, with their mod Entropy II to be found under the folowing link, [url=http://www.staredit.net/topic/2972/]official Topic of EII by one Author[/url] And last but not least, Lord Jafud, with his mod Eternal Duel: Earth vs Mars to be found under the following link, [url=http://www.staredit.net/topic/2904/]Official Topic of EDEM by Author[/url][/quote] Remember rate out of 5 (1/5) the following categories: Content: What was modded? How many units were there? Was it an extense tech tree? Was it so long that was boring? Did it mod extra stuff like music, AIs, consoles and everything else obscure? Completeness: Did it miss anything? Do you feel like the author didn't have time to complete it even after I changed the deadline 2 times summing up like a month and a half more and... okay enough. Fun factor: Was it awesomely fun? Again, was it boring? Was it so annoying because it was unbalanced? Originality: Did the mod present a really amazing new concept? Was it the same old classic space mod? Overall rating of the mod: no description. I'd appreciate if you did something like: [quote]ED, -1 content, 7 completeness, 6 fun, -17 originality, -0 overall[/quote] For each mod. Notice that they differ from the original judging criteria. This is because not everyone is a modder to understand everything at all. Lastly, I'd like you to rate the SMMM: Ratings higher than 5 are allowed here ;) (5 is still the highest, though :P but there's obviously something higher than 5) Fun: Was it fun? duh. Organization: Was it really organized? Did it lack something? Help us improve our organization skills! Overall rating: duh Here's my rating for the SMMM: [quote]SMMM, 10 fun, 5 organization, OVER NINETHOUSAND overall.[/quote] Good job Polaris :P The SMC III Topic can be unpinned now but still not closed.

So you have played 3 days in a row your favourite SMC III mod...
So you have seen the work that was done....
It's time to crush them!

Refering to this topic the polls are now open for public.
So, here's the deal:
- You must rate 1 out of 5 being 1 the lowest possible score and 5 the highest. Jokes like OMG I GIVE IT A 6 will result in the corban vision automatic script setting the
rating as 1, not 5, not the closet number to anything, 1.
- You can change your rating (to other mods) whenever you wish before the poll closes.
- The poll will close in.. say... hmm.. sunday? Sure, sunday sounds good.

I'll ask you to play the mod before rating it, yes a any random person can create an account and vote like a very mean person and it will be taken into consideration, of course, so, play the mods, please
Try to be as critical as possible, of course this poll is more for like "OMG ITS VOY SO I GIVE IT A 5" and it will still be valid but try to be critical

The mods you are rating are:

Quote

A_of_s_t, with his mod Critters vs Hunters to be found under the following link: Official Topic for CvH by Author
Killer_Kow & O)FaRTy1billion[MM], with their mod Etu Nimstal to be found under the following link: Official Topic for EN by one Author
Killer_Kow, with his last minute jokes and not to be considered for prizes but to be rated as well as others: Hello, Desktop, no ESCAPE, smC_JOKE_ENTRY.
Phobos[MM] & Polaris[MM] & Eternus & Voyager, with their mod Masters of Holocaust v1.1 to be found under the following link, Official Topic for MoH 1.1 by one Author
bajadulce & poiuy_qwert, with their mod Entropy II to be found under the folowing link, official Topic of EII by one Author
And last but not least, Lord Jafud, with his mod Eternal Duel: Earth vs Mars to be found under the following link, Official Topic of EDEM by Author

Remember rate out of 5 (1/5) the following categories:
Content: What was modded? How many units were there? Was it an extense tech tree? Was it so long that was boring? Did it mod extra stuff like music, AIs, consoles and everything else obscure?
Completeness: Did it miss anything? Do you feel like the author didn't have time to complete it even after I changed the deadline 2 times summing up like a month and a half more and... okay enough.
Fun factor: Was it awesomely fun? Again, was it boring? Was it so annoying because it was unbalanced?
Originality: Did the mod present a really amazing new concept? Was it the same old classic space mod?
Overall rating of the mod: no description.

I'd appreciate if you did something like:

Quote

ED, -1 content, 7 completeness, 6 fun, -17 originality, -0 overall

For each mod.

Notice that they differ from the original judging criteria. This is because not everyone is a modder to understand everything at all.
Lastly, I'd like you to rate the SMMM:
Ratings higher than 5 are allowed here (5 is still the highest, though but there's obviously something higher than 5)

Fun: Was it fun? duh.
Organization: Was it really organized? Did it lack something? Help us improve our organization skills!
Overall rating: duh


Here's my rating for the SMMM:

Quote

SMMM, 10 fun, 5 organization, OVER NINETHOUSAND overall.

Good job Polaris

The SMC III Topic can be unpinned now but still not closed.

[quote]Remember rate out of 5 (1/5) the following categories: Content: What was modded? How many units were there? Was it an extense tech tree? Was it so long that was boring? Did it mod extra stuff like music, [color=#CE091D]AIs[/color], consoles and everything else obscure?[/quote] [color=#CE091D]Typo. SMMM, fun 10, organization... 3. 10 Overall.[/color]

Quote

Remember rate out of 5 (1/5) the following categories:
Content: What was modded? How many units were there? Was it an extense tech tree? Was it so long that was boring? Did it mod extra stuff like music, AIs, consoles and everything else obscure?

Typo.
SMMM, fun 10, organization... 3. 10 Overall.

I don't get what you want us to do; do you want us to rate each mod individually?

I don't get what you want us to do; do you want us to rate each mod individually?

CvH: Content: 2 Completeness: 3 Fun factor: 1 Originality: 3 Overall rating of the mod: 2 Etu: Content: 4 Completeness: 4 Fun factor: 5 Originality: 3 Overall rating of the mod: 4 KK's joke entries: Content: 1 Completeness: 1 Fun factor: 1 Originality: 1 Overall rating of the mod: 1 KK's joke entries: Content: 1 Completeness: 1 Fun factor: 1 Originality: 1 Overall rating of the mod: 1 MoH: Content: 5 Completeness: 5 Fun factor: 5 Originality: 4 Overall rating of the mod: 5 EII Content: 3 Completeness: 4 Fun factor: 4 Originality: 2 Overall rating of the mod: 3 EDEM: Content: 4 Completeness: 4 Fun factor: 3 Originality: 3 Overall rating of the mod: 3 SMMM: Content: 5 Completeness: 5 Fun factor: 4 Originality: 4 Overall rating: 5 I believe the next SMMM, or even Mod Night 100 can be done even better with some changes.

CvH:
Content: 2
Completeness: 3
Fun factor: 1
Originality: 3
Overall rating of the mod: 2

Etu:
Content: 4
Completeness: 4
Fun factor: 5
Originality: 3
Overall rating of the mod: 4

KK's joke entries:
Content: 1
Completeness: 1
Fun factor: 1
Originality: 1
Overall rating of the mod: 1

KK's joke entries:
Content: 1
Completeness: 1
Fun factor: 1
Originality: 1
Overall rating of the mod: 1

MoH:
Content: 5
Completeness: 5
Fun factor: 5
Originality: 4
Overall rating of the mod: 5

EII
Content: 3
Completeness: 4
Fun factor: 4
Originality: 2
Overall rating of the mod: 3

EDEM:
Content: 4
Completeness: 4
Fun factor: 3
Originality: 3
Overall rating of the mod: 3

SMMM:
Content: 5
Completeness: 5
Fun factor: 4
Originality: 4
Overall rating: 5

I believe the next SMMM, or even Mod Night 100 can be done even better with some changes.

You have to at least give my joke entries points for originality :( Nobody else submitted joke entries :(

You have to at least give my joke entries points for originality Nobody else submitted joke entries

[quote=name:Killer_Kow]You have to at least give my joke entries points for originality :( Nobody else submitted joke entries :([/quote] I thought Hello Desktop was a real mod for 3 crashes. :bleh:

Quote from Killer_Kow[MM]

You have to at least give my joke entries points for originality Nobody else submitted joke entries

I thought Hello Desktop was a real mod for 3 crashes.

[quote=name:Excalibur][quote=name:Killer_Kow]You have to at least give my joke entries points for originality :( Nobody else submitted joke entries :([/quote] I thought Hello Desktop was a real mod for 3 crashes. :bleh:[/quote] LOL.

Quote from Excalibur[MM]

Quote from Killer_Kow[MM]

You have to at least give my joke entries points for originality Nobody else submitted joke entries

I thought Hello Desktop was a real mod for 3 crashes.

LOL.

Ex, I am stealing your layout. CvH: Content: 2 Completeness: 2 Fun factor: 1 Originality: 3 Overall rating of the mod: 2 -It just felt like it lacked something. There really wasn't much to the mod at all. It was different, I'll say that, but it was pretty boring, honestly. Etu: Content: 5 Completeness: 4 Fun factor: 4 Originality: 2 Overall rating of the mod: 4 Etu was fun. It was packed with tons of extra TBL edits, bin edits, and other fun things that made me give it a 5 in content. I would have given it a 5 in fun factor, but those Ferrus soldier were horribly IMBA, seeing as I got raped with them like, 5 times. It wasn't that original though; but, to me, fun overrides originality, so I could care less. KK's joke entries: Content: 1 Completeness: 1 Fun factor: 1 Originality: 1 Overall rating of the mod: 1 ... MoH: I cant rate my own mod. Even if I was allowed to, I couldn't. EII Content: 3 Completeness: 5 Fun factor: 4 Originality: 1 Overall rating of the mod: 3 Entropy was fun. Getting raped by AI is always fun. To an extent. It was complete, and offered a decent amount of AI's to fight against. I gave it a 1 in originality because... well, its an AI mod, not a total conversion or anything. Lots of AI mods are made, the only thing original about it is that he combined them all into 1. EDEM: Content: 5 Completeness: 4 Fun factor: 4 Originality: 3 Overall rating of the mod: 4 I liked this mod. There was a lot of work put into it, and it was pretty fun. A bit IMBA, but fun. It was a cool concept too. I liked the neutral race. But for the story line, it seemed a direct ripoff of the first 5 or 6 missions of the game Hegemonia. The mod also crashed for me a few times, unfortunately, so that bumped one point off of fun and completeness. SMMM: Content: 5 Completeness: 5 Fun factor: 5 Originality: 5 Overall rating: 5 WIN

Ex, I am stealing your layout.

CvH:
Content: 2
Completeness: 2
Fun factor: 1
Originality: 3
Overall rating of the mod: 2
-It just felt like it lacked something. There really wasn't much to the mod at all. It was different, I'll say that, but it was pretty boring, honestly.

Etu:
Content: 5
Completeness: 4
Fun factor: 4
Originality: 2
Overall rating of the mod: 4
Etu was fun. It was packed with tons of extra TBL edits, bin edits, and other fun things that made me give it a 5 in content. I would have given it a 5 in fun factor, but those Ferrus soldier were horribly IMBA, seeing as I got raped with them like, 5 times. It wasn't that original though; but, to me, fun overrides originality, so I could care less.

KK's joke entries:
Content: 1
Completeness: 1
Fun factor: 1
Originality: 1
Overall rating of the mod: 1
...

MoH:
I cant rate my own mod. Even if I was allowed to, I couldn't.

EII
Content: 3
Completeness: 5
Fun factor: 4
Originality: 1
Overall rating of the mod: 3
Entropy was fun. Getting raped by AI is always fun. To an extent. It was complete, and offered a decent amount of AI's to fight against. I gave it a 1 in originality because... well, its an AI mod, not a total conversion or anything. Lots of AI mods are made, the only thing original about it is that he combined them all into 1.

EDEM:
Content: 5
Completeness: 4
Fun factor: 4
Originality: 3
Overall rating of the mod: 4
I liked this mod. There was a lot of work put into it, and it was pretty fun. A bit IMBA, but fun. It was a cool concept too. I liked the neutral race. But for the story line, it seemed a direct ripoff of the first 5 or 6 missions of the game Hegemonia. The mod also crashed for me a few times, unfortunately, so that bumped one point off of fun and completeness.

SMMM:
Content: 5
Completeness: 5
Fun factor: 5
Originality: 5
Overall rating: 5
WIN

[quote=name:Polaris]Etu: Content: 5 Completeness: 4 Fun factor: 4 Originality: 2 Overall rating of the mod: 4 Etu was fun. It was packed with tons of extra TBL edits, bin edits, and other fun things that made me give it a 5 in content. I would have given it a 5 in fun factor, but those Ferrus soldier were horribly IMBA, seeing as I got raped with them like, 5 times. It wasn't that original though; but, to me, fun overrides originality, so I could care less.[/quote] You're supposed to counter them with Melvins >.< They're cheaper, faster, and specialize against infantry... I may look at it though. And if you're all wondering why I'm not posting my own marks, I am still yet to play a few of the mods.

Quote from Polaris[MM]

Etu:
Content: 5
Completeness: 4
Fun factor: 4
Originality: 2
Overall rating of the mod: 4
Etu was fun. It was packed with tons of extra TBL edits, bin edits, and other fun things that made me give it a 5 in content. I would have given it a 5 in fun factor, but those Ferrus soldier were horribly IMBA, seeing as I got raped with them like, 5 times. It wasn't that original though; but, to me, fun overrides originality, so I could care less.

You're supposed to counter them with Melvins >.< They're cheaper, faster, and specialize against infantry... I may look at it though.

And if you're all wondering why I'm not posting my own marks, I am still yet to play a few of the mods.

[quote=name:Polaris]MoH: I cant rate my own mod. Even if I was allowed to, I couldn't. [/quote] That layout is okay, easy enough. And you are allowed t rate your own mod. [quote]And if you're all wondering why I'm not posting my own marks, I am still yet to play a few of the mods.[/quote] You can submit what you have right now and come back later to edit with the other info.

Quote from Polaris[MM]

MoH:
I cant rate my own mod. Even if I was allowed to, I couldn't.

That layout is okay, easy enough.
And you are allowed t rate your own mod.

Quote

And if you're all wondering why I'm not posting my own marks, I am still yet to play a few of the mods.

You can submit what you have right now and come back later to edit with the other info.

[color=#CD0000]Be sapping Ex's and Polaris' layout. CvH: Content: 2 Completeness: 2 Fun factor: 2 Originality: 4 Overall rating of the mod: 3 -no comment- Etu: Content: 4 Completeness: 4 Fun factor: 5 Originality: 2 Overall rating of the mod: 4 To be a last minute mod it was pretty complete, you know? And the .bin and string editing was very cool. KK's joke entries: Content: 1 Completeness: 1 Fun factor: 1 Originality: 1 Overall rating of the mod: 1 ... MoH: I am in the same mod team as Polaris :P EII Content: - Completeness: - Fun factor: - Originality: - Overall rating of the mod: - -didn't get a chance to play it- EDEM: Content: 5 Completeness: 4 Fun factor: 4 Originality: 3 Overall rating of the mod: 4 It was pretty cool, it was original in some concepts like the layout o fthe console, however the minerlas were seen in SC (I know they're not quite the same, but...!). It was very IMBA in my opinion. I chose to play as Earth, and I just massed out the 2 basic-most units to win, and had loads and loads of minerals yet to use. SMMM: Content: 5 Completeness: 10 Fun factor: 10 Originality: 5 Overall rating: -10... j/k, it's 5[/color]

Be sapping Ex's and Polaris' layout.

CvH:
Content: 2
Completeness: 2
Fun factor: 2
Originality: 4
Overall rating of the mod: 3
-no comment-

Etu:
Content: 4
Completeness: 4
Fun factor: 5
Originality: 2
Overall rating of the mod: 4
To be a last minute mod it was pretty complete, you know? And the .bin and string editing was very cool.

KK's joke entries:
Content: 1
Completeness: 1
Fun factor: 1
Originality: 1
Overall rating of the mod: 1
...

MoH:
I am in the same mod team as Polaris

EII
Content: -
Completeness: -
Fun factor: -
Originality: -
Overall rating of the mod: -
-didn't get a chance to play it-

EDEM:
Content: 5
Completeness: 4
Fun factor: 4
Originality: 3
Overall rating of the mod: 4
It was pretty cool, it was original in some concepts like the layout o fthe console, however the minerlas were seen in SC (I know they're not quite the same, but...!). It was very IMBA in my opinion. I chose to play as Earth, and I just massed out the 2 basic-most units to win, and had loads and loads of minerals yet to use.

SMMM:
Content: 5
Completeness: 10
Fun factor: 10
Originality: 5
Overall rating: -10... j/k, it's 5

[quote=name:Killer_Kow][quote=name:Polaris]Etu was fun. It was packed with tons of extra TBL edits, bin edits, and other fun things that made me give it a 5 in content. I would have given it a 5 in fun factor, but those Ferrus soldier were horribly IMBA, seeing as I got raped with them like, 5 times. It wasn't that original though; but, to me, fun overrides originality, so I could care less.[/quote] You're supposed to counter them with Melvins >.< They're cheaper, faster, and specialize against infantry... I may look at it though.[/quote]You people also failed to upgrade. I'd rape you with 3/3 when I played. <3 People like my bin editing! (Both me and KK did strings. :P)

Quote from Killer_Kow[MM]

Quote from Polaris[MM]

Etu was fun. It was packed with tons of extra TBL edits, bin edits, and other fun things that made me give it a 5 in content. I would have given it a 5 in fun factor, but those Ferrus soldier were horribly IMBA, seeing as I got raped with them like, 5 times. It wasn't that original though; but, to me, fun overrides originality, so I could care less.

You're supposed to counter them with Melvins >.< They're cheaper, faster, and specialize against infantry... I may look at it though.

You people also failed to upgrade. I'd rape you with 3/3 when I played.

<3 People like my bin editing! (Both me and KK did strings. )

KK's joke entries: 5 5 5 5 Overall: 5 Im serious, they were the best mods I have ever played, ever.

KK's joke entries:
5
5
5
5
Overall: 5

Im serious, they were the best mods I have ever played, ever.

I would consider the SMMM a success. Could do with a bit more organization [i]during[/i] the even, though. Eventually we broke up into 2 groups playing different mods.

I would consider the SMMM a success. Could do with a bit more organization during the even, though. Eventually we broke up into 2 groups playing different mods.

But that's what made it even more fun!

But that's what made it even more fun!

So... Sunday's almost over but since I think no one else's gonna post in this missing hour and a half I'll just close the polls. If you still want to post something you can, and if you missed a mod to rate or something you can but not after 1 hour and a half passes from this minute. This topic is irrelevant now, It may be unpinned and closed tomorrow. I'll just go to bed right now :p I haven't slept in like months. Anyway, expect the SMC III results in a couple of [i]months.[/i] lol jking :P

So... Sunday's almost over but since I think no one else's gonna post in this missing hour and a half I'll just close the polls.
If you still want to post something you can, and if you missed a mod to rate or something you can but not after 1 hour and a half passes from this minute.

This topic is irrelevant now, It may be unpinned and closed tomorrow.
I'll just go to bed right now I haven't slept in like months.

Anyway, expect the SMC III results in a couple of months.
lol jking