I would still prefer a Kame lynch (no offense Kame, you're just the person I suspect the most because of your short role PM and willingness to lynch Aristocrat).
Have you read
this post? That conversation is essentially why I'm willing to believe why she'd vote Aristo.
EDIT:
If Kame is lynched and when she is revealed as Town, I'd like to thank everyone who voted for her as contributing to my list of suspects.
Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Oct 30 2012, 10:50 pm by DevliN.
Currently Working On: My Overwatch addiction.
An artist's depiction of an Extended Unit Death
Day 1 Vote Tally
Dem0n: Aristocrat
Fire_Kame: Aristocrat
Raccoon: Aristocrat
l)ark_ssj9kevin: Aristocrat
BiOAtK: Aristocrat
Leeroy_Jenkins: Aristocrat
Aristocrat: Aristocrat (7)
rayNimagi: Fire_Kame
NudeRaider: Fire_Kame
Stacy Keibler: Fire_Kame (3)
poison_us: Dem0n
Lanthanide: l)ark_ssj9kevin
Tempz: Abstain
DevliN: Abstain
LoTu)S: Abstain
Leon-037: Abstain
Observer12425: Abstain
FaRTy1billion: Abstain
Leading Candidate(s): AristocratCan we get a list of those who haven't voted at all tacked on the bottom for the next days, Roy?
The day post will list those who didn't vote, but it will not be included in the running tallies.
Have you read
this post? That conversation is essentially why I'm willing to believe why she'd vote Aristo.
I can understand why Kame would vote for Aristocrat, but I still don't think lynching townies because they have an "agenda" is a good idea. If Aristocrat is really a townsperson, he can't do anything by himself. If he is actually Mafia, then he could just kill those people on his own. Aristocrat may try to destroy the people on his hit list, but the rest of us can vote for suspected Mafia members.
And maybe Kame is actually town. I don't know. To me, she's just the most suspicious person right now, and that's why I voted for her.
I also re-examined the two role PM's in Devlin's link:
[2012-10-27. : 3:07 pm] Fire_Kame whispers to you -- "Nobody knows your background. They just assume on good faith that you're a townsperson." it wasn't a coverup. I'm trying to figure out why my role pm is so boring.
...
[2012-10-27. : 3:04 pm] HCM™Aristocrat whispers to Fire_Kame -- Oh, so you ARE mafia, lmao. "You are in crushing debt after dropping out of medical school. As it turns out, being a medical practitioner is a lot of work, and you don't like doing a lot of work. Instead, you got a cheap apartment right next to the grocery outlet, at which you work part-time doing janitorial service. Kate's Grocery. Who is Kate, anyway? You don't know, and you're too lazy to find out; it matters not to a townsperson. On weekends you like to hit up the pub with what little spending money you have; an empty stomach makes it easier to get inebriated, anyway. While you may not consider yourself to be a winner, you're happy enough to be alive."
I noticed that other role PMs end with some phrase indicating that you are taking action, like the ones that follow. Aristocrat's does not have this type of ending, so I am beginning to suspect him as well.
lil-inferno's Role PMQuote from name:lil-inferno's Role PM
... As CFO of the Kate's Grocery outlet, the largest store in the town, you are the most invested in figuring out if a person is an innocent townsperson or not. Every innocent life taken is another lost customer, after all.
Quote from name: My Role PM
You worked as a teller at the Diamond World Bank (which only had two branches), back before its financial collapse. Since then, you've done some odd jobs, jobs you'd rather not put on your resume. The point is, you keep a low profile as a regular townsperson, never taking an interest in politics or drama. Now that the Town is actually killing people through election, though, you've taken a different stance. This time, you can make a difference: you can save lives, or end them.
Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Oct 31 2012, 3:05 am by rayNimagi.
Win by luck, lose by skill.
That's fair, that you don't want to kill townies based solely on whether or not they have an agenda. I felt two things about Aristocrat's agenda: first, it would greatly obstruct justice to follow false leads he would plant in later lynchings. Second, as I was the only person he had told, I would be an accessory to needless and repeated townie lynches.
Is it possible his list included mafia? Yes, if he's a townie. But I believe it would be more just to use real clues and justification for lynches.
Aristocrat, I hope you have given your true list to someone, or that you will post it here. It is necessary to town survival to have all information available.
Ray that was not Demon's role PM. If you read what he posted, you would see that he said that was Inferno's role PM. Demon, however, did post post his role PM somewhere in the shoutbox at Aristocrat's request. It was something about science or something.
None.