[skip all navigation]

Using Africa for Farmland, Otherwise known as Foreign Invement Farming

Creator: Tempz
Time: Mar 11 2012, 12:11 pm

Post #1     Tempz Mar 11 2012, 12:11 pm

[Avatar]
What a caterpillar calls death a master calls a butterfly.
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Satire Comic



TL;DR Version
Food inflation or the economical bubble is an all too same sight is causing the need for food to be shifted onto poorer countries

(user posted image)

Basically foreign investment farming is a fancy term for a corporation such as McDonald giving money to a poor country with farmland to "develop"the area. I use the term ambiguously because the country usually obtains land that are desperately needed for the people or destroys their forests (Source)


The big deal of this is because the chain of events called cause and effect... eliminating place such as the rainforest absolutely destroys biodiversity (Source), causes more carbon monoxide to be place in the area, and so take food from country that already heavily depends on foreign aid (explained below).

What is forcing this... over population thus to overcome this we increase supply. It may seem that we are trying to help Africa by providing a means to farm and be self substaining but this false imo... I believe that the corporations that are funding the operation in the poor country sole intent it use the land of a poor country to send back to usa and other wealthy countries so that they can keep a failing system going. Even i have no directly stated proof i did find this quote which states
Quote
Malian land have been leased
(Source)

Which means land is not really owned by the farmers but by the corporation that loaned it out. Doesn't sound so bad at first but if you think about it carefully this means that the farmer has an obligation to send what meager crops they grow go back to the investor meaning the agricultural wealth is simply transferred back to wealthiest players so not much is gained by the farmers in the end.
(user posted image)


Outlook to the future at least for me is bleak because our dependance and addiction to oil will soon cause the UN-renewable resource to be shifted on bio-fuels causing even more strain and inflation on food causing mass starvation thus more farming land will be needed looping the cycle over and over again. So all this has done is slow the inevitable food bubble; its now we are left with a system bursting at its seams.

Truth hurts. Maybe not as much as jumping on a bicycle with a seat missing, but it hurts.
- Drebin (Naked Gun 2 1/2)
Pm me for terrain requests (Jungle mostly)
(user posted image)
Top

Post #2     Heinermann Mar 11 2012, 3:03 pm

[Avatar]
BWAPI Project Owner
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Let's waste 50% of food and then claim we don't have enough.
And instead of improving agriculture, let's just use more land.

Top

Post #3     matefkr Mar 12 2012, 5:13 pm

[Avatar]
bannedcontact
Rank: Member
it can be solved by activists who know stuff which can help poor countries, so theat stuff is told to the poor, and the poor wont think they need help from corporations.

Top

Post #4     Sacrieur Mar 13 2012, 6:14 am

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Quote from matefkr
it can be solved by activists who know stuff which can help poor countries, so theat stuff is told to the poor, and the poor wont think they need help from corporations.

I don't know what you're saying here.

∫ | ⅛ ⅓ ⅜ ⅝ ⅔ ⅞ | π φ ∞ | ≡ ≈ ≥ ≤ ∴ ∩ | √ ⁿ | ✓ ✗ | א
α β Γγ ∆∂ ε ζ η Θθ Ιι κ Λλ μ Ξξ Π ρ Σσς τ υ Φ Ψψ Ωω
(user posted image) (user posted image)
Top

Post #5     Xlil-InfernoDDD Mar 14 2012, 6:57 pm

[Avatar]
"Pretentiously quoting myself" -lil-Inferno
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Quote from Sacrieur
Quote from matefkr
it can be solved by activists who know stuff which can help poor countries, so theat stuff is told to the poor, and the poor wont think they need help from corporations.

I don't know what you're saying here.
✓ Poor
✓ Corporations
✓ Activists

I'm not sure what he's trying to communicate either. It seems more like he's attempting to know what he's talking about (by saying corporations and activists) which I interpreted as those with knowledge passing their knowledge to third world countries, which... really won't help them.

(user posted image)
Top

Post #6     Fire_Kame Mar 14 2012, 7:29 pm

[Avatar]
The Means By Which All Is Revealed
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Everyone in this topic seems to be painting as monochromatic black and white. If only corporation XYZ stepped back, then we'd be able to send humanitarians, and they'd actually do something! There are other issues at play here, one of them being...
Quote from Heinermann
Let's waste 50% of food and then claim we don't have enough.
And instead of improving agriculture, let's just use more land.

America, and I would gamble most of the first world, is INCREDIBLY wasteful with how we view food. There was a reason preservatives were created, and quite a few of them are not going to kill you. Do you really need to sample that food before buying it? Is that bread really going to mold ten minutes after the expiration date hits? And people who don't FIFO or follow stocking procedures - I pulled a dozen loaves of bread of one type last time I closed, because some moron decided to stock out 8 of each flavor instead of two or three (like I had suggested the last time I did this). People who open product, touch product, or try product and then demand it warmed up a little - do they not realize as soon as they touch something unwrapped I can't sell it again? I can't reheat it with a steam wand or slice it because it qualifies as contamination. And the mentality that leads to this - if things aren't stocked appealingly then people won't buy it, because something there is inferred that the product out must be 'bad' or 'old' if there's only one out...meaning we have to stock out more...which won't sell...so that that one looks better.

There are other issues, but this one really hit me. The only good thing I can say is that any food that is pulled at the end of the night (unless its moldy or contaminated) we donate to food banks in the area. But charity starts at home.

lather the blood on your hands, Romeo
Top

Post #7     Sacrieur Mar 14 2012, 11:24 pm

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Don't worry, I have a food replicator in the works.

∫ | ⅛ ⅓ ⅜ ⅝ ⅔ ⅞ | π φ ∞ | ≡ ≈ ≥ ≤ ∴ ∩ | √ ⁿ | ✓ ✗ | א
α β Γγ ∆∂ ε ζ η Θθ Ιι κ Λλ μ Ξξ Π ρ Σσς τ υ Φ Ψψ Ωω
(user posted image) (user posted image)
Top

Post #8     Fire_Kame Mar 14 2012, 11:36 pm

[Avatar]
The Means By Which All Is Revealed
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Quote from Sacrieur
Don't worry, I have a food replicator in the works.
The funny thing is, given the societal backlash of GMO products, the food replicator will probably have a similar response. Think about the conspiracies that have come about from GMO and from similar things - and I'm not just talking about it tasting better.

lather the blood on your hands, Romeo
Top

Post #9     Tempz Mar 15 2012, 12:12 am

[Avatar]
What a caterpillar calls death a master calls a butterfly.
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
For those who don't know it stands for genetically modified organisms

Truth hurts. Maybe not as much as jumping on a bicycle with a seat missing, but it hurts.
- Drebin (Naked Gun 2 1/2)
Pm me for terrain requests (Jungle mostly)
(user posted image)
Top

Post #10     Sacrieur Mar 15 2012, 12:24 am

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Quote from Fire_Kame
Quote from Sacrieur
Don't worry, I have a food replicator in the works.
The funny thing is, given the societal backlash of GMO products, the food replicator will probably have a similar response. Think about the conspiracies that have come about from GMO and from similar things - and I'm not just talking about it tasting better.

Willfully ignorant? NOT MY PROBLEM.

More for me.

∫ | ⅛ ⅓ ⅜ ⅝ ⅔ ⅞ | π φ ∞ | ≡ ≈ ≥ ≤ ∴ ∩ | √ ⁿ | ✓ ✗ | א
α β Γγ ∆∂ ε ζ η Θθ Ιι κ Λλ μ Ξξ Π ρ Σσς τ υ Φ Ψψ Ωω
(user posted image) (user posted image)
Top

Post #11     rockz Mar 16 2012, 1:59 pm

[Avatar]
お や す み
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
(user posted image)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland)

dear god it's happening again.

This is a great wallpaper to use if you want to go into an epileptic fit every time you sit down in front of your laptop, which I guess is a better option than watching Naruto.
Top

Post #12     Fire_Kame Mar 16 2012, 7:23 pm

[Avatar]
The Means By Which All Is Revealed
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
I don't see the connection, rockz.

The Potato Famine in Ireland was largely due to dependency on the potato crop, so that when it suffered (or when over farming the land for it sucked out nutrients) it took most of the country with it. Although the first world - namely America - is dependent on wheat or corn, we are much better about farming it now, and there is an ample supply of substitutes. If you truly wish to go the path that wheat/corn based products are geared towards the lower class, I will say it is just a easy to buy quinoa with foodstamps as it would be to buy wheat products.

I don't mean to hand wave our own problems, especially with malnutrition, but comparing the occasional tomato crop freezing to the potato famine is a pretty steep slippery slope argument.

The question here is whether or not it is ethical to buy farmland from other countries who are struggling to feed their own people, not if we're going to face a mass extinction due to food inflation.

lather the blood on your hands, Romeo
Top

Post #13     matefkr Mar 16 2012, 8:08 pm

[Avatar]
bannedcontact
Rank: Member
i was talking about the fact that teaching poor people in shit countries might help them. This way they wont sell their land to outsider corporations in hope of getting help.

Top

Post #14     Fire_Kame Mar 17 2012, 6:22 am

[Avatar]
The Means By Which All Is Revealed
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Quote from matefkr
i was talking about the fact that teaching poor people in shit countries might help them. This way they wont sell their land to outsider corporations in hope of getting help.
I hate to break it to you, but some of the biggest humanitarian efforts are shrouded with controversy. Not to say you should only trust the critics of organizations, but its not a good idea to blindly assume nonprofits/not-for-profits don't have something to gain by helping troubled countries.

Also, don't cuss. It makes your argument sound less intelligent.

lather the blood on your hands, Romeo
Top

Post #15     EzTerix Mar 17 2012, 10:20 am

[Avatar]
offlinecontact
Rank: Regular
Once the world economy starts to stagnate I wonder if Africa will be left behind for eternity or ... foreign development ... as in oil rigs, mines, and ripping off even more farms lmao.

As far as I'm concerned if the government corruption and public knowledge isn't improving in Africa then the select countries will be left in the dust. If I had to guess South Africa, Nigeria, and some North African countries, and a couple others will improve while the rest are gonna still be complete shit 50 years from now and we'll just drain their resources dry.

Top

Post #16     matefkr Mar 19 2012, 1:40 pm

[Avatar]
bannedcontact
Rank: Member
Quote from Fire_Kame
Quote from matefkr
i was talking about the fact that teaching poor people in shit countries might help them. This way they wont sell their land to outsider corporations in hope of getting help.
I hate to break it to you, but some of the biggest humanitarian efforts are shrouded with controversy. Not to say you should only trust the critics of organizations, but its not a good idea to blindly assume nonprofits/not-for-profits don't have something to gain by helping troubled countries.

Also, don't cuss. It makes your argument sound less intelligent.

Of course, i got it. But i was implying direct help (helping the poor, not helping others who allegedly help them).

Top

Post #17     rockz Mar 19 2012, 2:24 pm

[Avatar]
お や す み
offlinecontact
Rank: Veteran
Quote from Fire_Kame
I don't see the connection, rockz.
Ireland was a net exporter during the potato famine to England. They shipped out all their good food before keeping it for themselves.

Irish farmers were already having trouble supporting their family. They had to switch to potatoes to feed their family because they were so cheap and fed so much. I'm afraid that if other countries start buying farmland in other areas and a plague does hit which ruins crops, we will see something similar, especially if the companies keep exporting all the good crops.

I can't say it will happen again, in fact I'd like to believe that in such a situation the companies would feed the population and take a loss for the year. But who knows what might happen? I'm of the opinion that efficiency is key. It is not efficient to produce electronics in china then ship them all across the world. Likewise it is not efficient to grow food in Africa, send it to Europe, then send it back to Africa. If it's cheaper that way, then there is a serious problem somewhere.
This post was edited 1 time, last edit by rockz: Mar 19 2012, 2:59 pm.

This is a great wallpaper to use if you want to go into an epileptic fit every time you sit down in front of your laptop, which I guess is a better option than watching Naruto.
Top
0 members in this topic (italic members are currently writing a reply): None
+ guest(s)


[03:36 pm]
Roy -- Please fix, Devourer.
[03:34 pm]
Roy -- I broke the report notifications.
[03:24 pm]
Azrael -- Someday!
[03:24 pm]
Azrael -- Should be able to split posts off into their own thread, then you could just merge that thread with the target one :P
[03:23 pm]
Azrael -- Oh, I'm sorry to hear that :(
[03:18 pm]
Roy -- We can't move individual posts, just topics.
[03:17 pm]
Azrael -- Definitely very out of place in that forum/topic/context.
Please log in to shout.