Staredit Network > Forums > Null > Topic: DevliN's Mafia: Battlestar Galactica
DevliN's Mafia: Battlestar Galactica
Sep 28 2011, 9:42 am
By: DevliN
Pages: < 1 34 35 36 37 >
 

Oct 20 2011, 1:39 pm Norm Post #701



Obviously, what I am saying is that we were originally banking on a plan that would have completely avoided all of that, and caused the town to get even more destroyed than they ended up being this game.



None.

Oct 20 2011, 1:43 pm Roy Post #702

An artist's depiction of an Extended Unit Death

And what I'm saying was that unless you deployed this plan for everyone on your team prior to the end of Night 2, I still would have had a formidable list based on behavior. In fact, a rush to publicly organize such a plan would probably just help me see what's going on. Sorry, but I'm not convinced.




Oct 20 2011, 1:45 pm Norm Post #703



You're not getting what Im saying...



None.

Oct 20 2011, 4:09 pm poison_us Post #704

Back* from the grave

Norm, Roy sees through your plans.
Roy, you don't understand Norm.


We good now?





Oct 20 2011, 4:23 pm Roy Post #705

An artist's depiction of an Extended Unit Death

Ah, thanks poison.

On a side note, I expected Norm to be investigated as innocent if he was a Hitman.




Oct 20 2011, 7:34 pm DevliN Post #706

OVERWATCH STATUS GO

Quote from Norm
You're not getting what Im saying...
He is getting what you're saying. I think what you're missing is that he suspected you and would have continued to suspect you regardless of the investigation.

Based on behavior, it was pretty clear that you were Mafia. Last game you jumped to conclusions and accused random people of being Mafia when they weren't. This game you kept telling people not to jump to conclusions and didn't really accuse anyone. If I was playing, I would have voted for you immediately because of that. I think what makes Roy such a good Mafia player is that not only does he look for clues, but he studies how people act and react, and for most players that is a dead giveaway.



\:devlin\: Currently Working On: \:devlin\:
My Overwatch addiction.

Oct 20 2011, 9:32 pm TiKels Post #707




Gay


Who's hosting next?



"If a topic that clearly interest noone needs to be closed to underline the "we don't want this here" message, is up to debate."

-NudeRaider

Oct 20 2011, 9:42 pm Aristocrat Post #708



Lol, yaoi.

TiKels: Azrael gave me his spot, but I don't have time, so I'm going to hand it over to Roy.



None.

Oct 20 2011, 10:34 pm Tempz Post #709



Yay... Roy's Mafia is the probably the best balance of clue difficulty (not too easy not too hard). But devlin did a very good job balancing this game.



None.

Oct 21 2011, 1:09 am Roy Post #710

An artist's depiction of an Extended Unit Death

Quote from Aristocrat
Azrael gave me his spot, but I don't have time, so I'm going to hand it over to Roy.
I have 11-hour class days and I'm an academic coach for 76 students. I'd love to host again, but I would definitely be unable to keep it as fast-paced and detailed as I normally would. If neither you nor Azrael are willing and able to host a game, and if nobody else is willing and able to host a game, I can host a stripped down version of my regular mod (i.e., less roles and no characteristics), but I'd prefer to not be responsible for hosting until my schedule loosens up (about four weeks from now).

TL;DR: I'd like to, but maybe someone else should.




Oct 21 2011, 1:36 am OlimarandLouie Post #711



I got another one in the works, it'll be finished by the time the next one is over.

Everyone gets aliases, all of which will be listed. Clues, votes, and actions are all done on the aliases, not players themselves.



None.

Oct 21 2011, 2:58 am Azrael Post #712



When I claimed the next spot originally, I had added "Aristocrat can go before me if he's able to host Death Note mafia at that time."

Since he is not, and Roy is also unable to (and few other hosts could manage it), I will simply be going on to host my mafia game.

Expect the sign-up thread before I go to sleep tonight.




Oct 21 2011, 3:25 am Norm Post #713



Quote from name:Azrael.Wrath
When I claimed the next spot originally, I had added "Aristocrat can go before me if he's able to host Death Note mafia at that time."

Since he is not, and Roy is also unable to (and few other hosts could manage it), I will simply be going on to host my mafia game.

Expect the sign-up thread before I go to sleep tonight.

And didn't you have a list somewhere of who is after you? Pretty sure I'm on there somewhere.. :S



None.

Oct 21 2011, 3:29 am Azrael Post #714



Quote from Norm
And didn't you have a list somewhere of who is after you? Pretty sure I'm on there somewhere.. :S

Yes, after me is Voyager, Poison, Roy, then you ^^




Oct 21 2011, 3:34 am Vrael Post #715



To the remaining townies who lived after I died, I'm curious:

Why didn't you guys lynch Azrael? I thought I made it blatantly obvious that he was a cylon. I was talking with NudeRaider and he said I made a bad case; clearly he was right. So I want to know, why wasn't anyone convinced?

Edit:
Sure it'll look obvious in hindsight. I'm wondering why no one believed me as it was happening.

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Oct 21 2011, 3:58 am by Vrael.



None.

Oct 21 2011, 4:18 am Azrael Post #716



It wasn't that you made a bad case, it's that you made it at the wrong time. If you had bit your tongue for a little while, you wouldn't have died that night, and then you could have made your case at the start of the next lynch. I'm sure you could have gotten me lynched if you'd done that (which was partially why I killed you).

If you were sure, your best bet would have been to publicly claim that you were sure I was innocent, in order to ensure you weren't framed or hit that night. Then you'd want to have your text wall ready for when the night ended, preceded with an explanation that your previous claim was entirely false, made only to ensure you lived long enough to expose me properly.

It would have given you that much more time to flesh out your argument against me, and Devlin may have dropped another obvious hint, thinking no one had picked up on the previous ones which you had already found.

In short, it was less about what you said, and more about when you said it.




Oct 21 2011, 4:21 am Tempz Post #717



That and my random voting which ultimately made the town lose lol.



None.

Oct 21 2011, 4:42 am poison_us Post #718

Back* from the grave

Quote from TiKels

Gay
Always wondered what the yellow shit to the right of his head was.

EDIT: Also, I could host a speedmafia. Next to no clues, 12-hour cycles maximum...would be a blast.





Oct 21 2011, 5:18 am Vrael Post #719



Quote from name:Azrael.Wrath
In short, it was less about what you said, and more about when you said it.
Still, you'd think someone in the town would've at least thought it was suspicious that I kick the bucket right after making a big deal over an obvious cylon? The clues were pretty damn incriminating, and no one picked up on it at all, I was very dissapointed.

Also, I was leaving town for the weekend, I didn't have a choice about when to post what I had, but even if I hadn't been going away, I would've posted that asap. Isn't it better for the town to have as much info as possible?



None.

Oct 21 2011, 6:03 am Azrael Post #720



It depends. It is only best for the Town to know information if knowing that information benefits them. You were looking at it from the point of view of a Townie giving helpful information to other Townies, however you need to look at things from the perspective of other players in order to strategize properly. From their point of view, it was a possible Mafia giving possibly misleading information to Townies. There was no way that your post would carry any weight by the next day unless you were there to bring it all back up again.

You publicized the information right after a known Mafia had been bandwagoned, there was no way you were going to get me lynched. All you succeeded in doing was making yourself a target and giving me ample time to dismantle your proposed evidence. I explained your findings in a way that gave reasonable doubt to your claims. By the time the next lynch came around, enough time had passed to ensure no one would take your post seriously. I said you were wrong, I was framed, and the Mafia killed you to make me look guilty. That was enough.

Had you done the exact same thing at the beginning of the next lynch instead, people would have voted with you, and you'd have gained support from people that believed you were correct. The reason this didn't happen was because of your timing, you posted it at a time when no Townie could possibly be benefited by openly supporting you, the night hits were about to start so all they could accomplish was getting themselves killed. Riney did what he could to try to protect you, but unfortunately for you he was simultaneously seduced.

Of course, protecting you shouldn't have been necessary, posting that information right when the night was about to start was foolish at best and suicide at worst. If you were worried you might die before you could share it, then you should have given it to another Townie and told them to post it for you in the case of your death.

The fact was, we had already picked our targets for the next night before you posted that, and you weren't one of them. Then you started trying to incriminate me and Inferno, and you left us no choice but to kill you immediately. You would have been a lot more successful in your attempts had you waited until the next day.




Options
Pages: < 1 34 35 36 37 >
  Back to forum
Please log in to reply to this topic or to report it.
Members in this topic: None.
[12:25 am]
lil-Inferno -- u
[07:17 pm]
zsnakezz -- ya
[2020-2-18. : 5:07 am]
KrayZee -- Corbo
Corbo shouted: gotta be fast
Shut up Sonic.
[2020-2-18. : 1:38 am]
Wing Zero -- The reset time for the boxes is inconvenient for me atm
[2020-2-18. : 1:01 am]
Corbo -- gotta be fast
[2020-2-17. : 11:33 pm]
Dem0n -- gotta be quicker
[2020-2-17. : 11:33 pm]
Dem0n -- ya
[2020-2-17. : 11:25 pm]
Wing Zero -- two weeks
[2020-2-17. : 11:25 pm]
Wing Zero -- in like
[2020-2-17. : 11:25 pm]
Wing Zero -- I haven't gotten my box
Please log in to shout.


Members Online: ydotes, audrinaofitzgerald, jjf28, razorback9423, Sie_Sayoka, ehycedeb