Staredit Network > Forums > Null > Topic: Atheists and Fate
Atheists and Fate
Sep 3 2009, 4:37 pm
By: Fire_Kame
Pages: < 1 « 2 3 4 5 >
 

Sep 17 2009, 12:12 am Neki Post #61



Quote from grAffe
zany, do you not realize that the ONLY reason you are Christian is because:
1. You just HAPPENED to be born within a Christian family
2. You have a gullible personality/a lesser tendency to question the world around you.
If it were not for these two conditions, you'd "be going to hell."
Ask yourself why you don't believe in the infinite other religions which existed since the dawn of mankind. If all you can come up with are subjective experiences like "Oh, I FELT God, therefore, he must be real" then you're not alone. I can show you a guy from Iraq, India, or Israel who would say the same exact thing, but instead about THEIR "one and only" God(s)"

Quote
God's will WANTS us to punish evildoers and criminals. It's pointed out many times in the Bible. So we'd be questioning God's will by NOT punishing that criminal. And I don't know a huge amount about this, but I do know that it isn't God doing the crime. It's the criminal. So the criminal can't say that God MADE him do it. Again, I don't know a huge lot on this point but it would be more accurate to say that God already knew that he would do that crime, and He is allowing the criminals sinful nature to take control.
Why doesn't he get off his lazy ass and do it himself? How do you know what God wants? How can you talk on behalf of somebody you aren't even sure exists, let alone what he says? Why does this all seem like a poorly written story full of plotholes? Why does God seem less and less omnipotent/omniscient as one reads more of the Bible? Why are there talking snakes, rib women, giant floods that wiped out God's mistakes, virgin births, people turning into pillars of salt, the conversion of water to alcohol, and when all of a sudden when everything is able to be recorded/taped/verified, it just STOPS? And if you start telling me to stop taking things so literally, YOU DON'T GET TO CHOOSE WHAT'S LITERAL AND WHAT'S NOT. And plus, the only reason your religion exists is BECAUSE of the Bible's literal words. It's a vicious cycle.

Though I am agnostic (I guess), you're being a bit off the wall here. Just because someone believes in Christianity doesn't make them any less gullable then anyone who believes in any other religion or none at all. You can't tell someone why they believe in something, it's their choice to their religion. I can't see how this has anything to do with Atheists and Fate at all. All you're doing is attacking his religion.



None.

Sep 17 2009, 12:27 am grAffe Post #62



Whatever, I was harsh. It's just kinda frustrating when somebody thinks differently than I do and I'm very sure that this person is wrong. He's Christian. He understands how I feel.

btw I thought the null section was a little less strict when it comes to a post's relevance to the topic. I guess I was wrong.



None.

Sep 17 2009, 12:32 am Vrael Post #63



Lol no you weren't wrong, its much more lenient here. No one's moderated the topic. Just don't try to pull that sort of thing in SD.

On the topic though, whether or not everything is predetermined can be true or false irrespective of what the aetheist believes. The real question of the issue is whether or not things are actually predetermined, and not necessarily what the belief of the person in question is.



None.

Sep 17 2009, 12:33 am CaptainWill Post #64



@graffe guy

Yes, but that doesn't mean turning the topic into a Christian vs. Atheist flamefest when it was originally about a completely unrelated point (which personally I find a lot more interesting) ok.



None.

Sep 17 2009, 12:35 am Jack Post #65

>be faceless void >mfw I have no face

If a mod could split the topic? Maybe call the new one zany vs ALL xD



Red classic.

"In short, their absurdities are so extreme that it is painful even to quote them."

Sep 17 2009, 12:37 am CaptainWill Post #66



Quote from name:zany_001
If a mod could split the topic? Maybe call the new one zany vs ALL xD

Well, the problem with that is that we have had very similar topics before and they nearly always end with several people being modded and the topic being locked. :P



None.

Sep 17 2009, 12:39 am Jack Post #67

>be faceless void >mfw I have no face

Ah. Well, graffe, I could explain myself and you could counter argue but it's not going to change how you or I think, so let's call it quits.

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Sep 17 2009, 12:40 am by zany_001. Reason: I DIDN'T MAKE A SPELLING MISTAKE! Honest?



Red classic.

"In short, their absurdities are so extreme that it is painful even to quote them."

Sep 17 2009, 1:10 am grAffe Post #68



lol I wasn't trying to convert you. I just wanted to see what your arguments would be. I used to be Christian, and I like Jesus, but I don't like the Bible or the God described in it.

Let's get back on topic, nao. I don't actually believe in fate, but I use the word "fate" to represent how "screwed" people are the moment they were born under the circumstances they were. We, for instance, are lucky to be born in this century, able to be living in this country, so our general fate is a good life.



None.

Sep 17 2009, 1:44 am Norm Post #69



Quote from grAffe
lol I wasn't trying to convert you. I just wanted to see what your arguments would be. I used to be Christian, and I like Jesus, but I don't like the Bible or the God described in it.

Let's get back on topic, nao. I don't actually believe in fate, but I use the word "fate" to represent how "screwed" people are the moment they were born under the circumstances they were. We, for instance, are lucky to be born in this century, able to be living in this country, so our general fate is a good life.

On the contrary, We would be even more lucky to have been born in an earlier point in human history.



None.

Sep 18 2009, 7:09 pm ejac1337 Post #70



Quote from Fire_Kame
If you're an atheist, answer this for me. It's been bothering for almost fifteen hours now.

Atheists do not believe that there is some almighty being guiding them around with a predeclared fate waiting to fall on them, right?

Many atheists believe that evolution, not creationism, is what created humans the way they are today (notice the qualifier many.)

Evolution, as far as natural selection is concerned, is determined through genetic mutations that either cause you to die or survive better.

Genetics are passed down from your parents without any say of what you want them to be.

Thus, isn't your fate already decided?

If you have a genetic mutation that means you have Downs Syndrome for the rest of your life, how could you possibly stop it?

I really don't understand your question sorry but the fact that you used the words "genetic mutation" when describing evolution shows you have little understanding of the matter. For the most part there are no mutations in evolution, simply extremely gradual changes over a long time. If person A can run at 1.001 mph (this is slow, I dont care), and person B can run at 1.002 mph, person B will have a .0001% higher chance of reproducing, and over hundreds, thousands, of generations (not years, generations) persons B genetics will take over the population.



None.

Sep 18 2009, 7:29 pm Greo Post #71



Quote from Fire_Kame
If you're an atheist, answer this for me. It's been bothering for almost fifteen hours now.
Atheists do not believe that there is some almighty being guiding them around with a predeclared fate waiting to fall on them, right?
Many atheists believe that evolution, not creationism, is what created humans the way they are today (notice the qualifier many.)
Evolution, as far as natural selection is concerned, is determined through genetic mutations that either cause you to die or survive better.
Genetics are passed down from your parents without any say of what you want them to be.
Thus, isn't your fate already decided?
If you have a genetic mutation that means you have Downs Syndrome for the rest of your life, how could you possibly stop it?
You've got so many things about predestination wrong. When someone is determined to have Down Syndrome, they're pretty much boned, but that doesn't necessarily mean predestination; you can't determine when or where they'll die, or how their life will be from that point. You can, however, make educated guesses and predict their 'fate', but you can't outright determine when exactly they'll die unless you've somehow found a way to travel to the future and back (which is nigh-impossible).



None.

Sep 18 2009, 7:43 pm ClansAreForGays Post #72



Quote from Greo
Quote from Fire_Kame
If you're an atheist, answer this for me. It's been bothering for almost fifteen hours now.
Atheists do not believe that there is some almighty being guiding them around with a predeclared fate waiting to fall on them, right?
Many atheists believe that evolution, not creationism, is what created humans the way they are today (notice the qualifier many.)
Evolution, as far as natural selection is concerned, is determined through genetic mutations that either cause you to die or survive better.
Genetics are passed down from your parents without any say of what you want them to be.
Thus, isn't your fate already decided?
If you have a genetic mutation that means you have Downs Syndrome for the rest of your life, how could you possibly stop it?
You've got so many things about predestination wrong. When someone is determined to have Down Syndrome, they're pretty much boned, but that doesn't necessarily mean predestination; you can't determine when or where they'll die, or how their life will be from that point. You can, however, make educated guesses and predict their 'fate', but you can't outright determine when exactly they'll die unless you've somehow found a way to travel to the future and back (which is nigh-impossible).
I'd like to point out that is EXACTLY what predestination is. :wallbash:

I keep forgetting this isn't SD it's null, where comments as dumb as this one have every right to exist, and reported it on accident. My apologies.




Sep 18 2009, 7:45 pm Greo Post #73



Quote from ClansAreForGays
I'd like to point out that is EXACTLY what predestination is. :wallbash:
I keep forgetting this isn't SD, where comments as dumb as this one have every right to exist, and reported it on accident. My apologies.
So, predestination = guessing. Got it.



None.

Sep 18 2009, 7:50 pm ClansAreForGays Post #74



:wtfage: try again
Quote
When someone is determined to have Down Syndrome, they're pretty much boned, but that doesn't necessarily mean predestination; you can't determine when or where they'll die, or how their life will be from that point.
It's what you said it isn't here, with one glaring exception. The way you're implying it, you make it sound like predestination has something to do with humans knowing exactly what is going to happen, which is an invention of your own and having nothing to do with predestination. Look up fortune telling for that.




Sep 18 2009, 7:55 pm Greo Post #75



Quote from ClansAreForGays
:wtfage: try again
Quote
When someone is determined to have Down Syndrome, they're pretty much boned, but that doesn't necessarily mean predestination; you can't determine when or where they'll die, or how their life will be from that point.
It's what you said it isn't here, with one glaring exception. The way you're implying it, you make it sound like predestination has something to do with humans knowing exactly what is going to happen, which is an invention of your own and having nothing to do with predestination. Look up fortune telling for that.
So, then don't say it's exactly like predestination if it's not. And mind you, you don't have to be a fortune teller to predict the future.



None.

Sep 18 2009, 8:02 pm Bar Refaeli Post #76



I think fate is decided for you, except you can chose to change that, though many don't. You and your mind make decisions based on the situation you are in. And those decisions are usually unchangeable unless you try and make a stand. Take the idea of life, we are living through life and then just dying at the end. What we do or want to do in the middle? We get an education first off. How an education helps you in life? Who knows. People could say that getting an education makes you a successful person. Then you get a job because you got a good education. How a job helps you in life? Who knows. People want money, and jobs give you money. Money gives you the ability to survive and indulge yourself in luxuries. What is the point in luxuries in life? To make your life better? How does this make your life better? Does it make it go by faster just so you can die sooner? Explain to me that, and then I will believe there is no such thing as destiny.

But then there are those people who stand out and think about life, and try to understand its many meanings. Not close minded scientists, but every day people who go to bed at night thinking about how life works. Will those people ever find an answer? Most likely not, but it is still always nice to think and dream.

But for now, we are all slaves of destiny.



None.

Sep 18 2009, 8:13 pm Greo Post #77



Quote from name:Raccoon
But for now, we are all slaves of destiny.
Then I'll keep fighting destiny. After all, I could counter this idea of worthless lives with endless dreams.
Why bother having a job? It's not so much as to make life better, but to make life worth living. What's the point of having luxuries? The real question is what's the point of living as a miser? Why bother getting an education? So we can experience life as well as we can. If you want to believe we're just 'living through life and then just dying at the end', then why do you still persist?

We live so that we can experience life, and learn what we want to learn, and experience everything that the world has to offer, and eventually carry life onwards as long as we can. Not any one of us is eternal, but humanity in a whole? I'd say we've got a long way to go before the universe explodes or however the world ends, so why not keep it like that?



None.

Sep 18 2009, 8:21 pm Bar Refaeli Post #78



Quote from Greo
Quote from name:Raccoon
But for now, we are all slaves of destiny.
Then I'll keep fighting destiny. After all, I could counter this idea of worthless lives with endless dreams.
Why bother having a job? It's not so much as to make life better, but to make life worth living. What's the point of having luxuries? The real question is what's the point of living as a miser? Why bother getting an education? So we can experience life as well as we can. If you want to believe we're just 'living through life and then just dying at the end', then why do you still persist?

We live so that we can experience life, and learn what we want to learn, and experience everything that the world has to offer, and eventually carry life onwards as long as we can. Not any one of us is eternal, but humanity in a whole? I'd say we've got a long way to go before the universe explodes or however the world ends, so why not keep it like that?
While life, of course, has its many joys and sorrows, is there any reason for us to learn and experience everything the world has to offer? And people don't follow that. When you think about the average person in the US, they just wake up every morning and go to a job that takes up all their day, then they get married and have kids later on, keep on working, then they retire and lounge around. I hardly call this experiencing all of life's joys and happenings.



None.

Sep 18 2009, 8:24 pm Greo Post #79



Quote from name:Raccoon
While life, of course, has its many joys and sorrows, is there any reason for us to learn and experience everything the world has to offer? And people don't follow that. When you think about the average person in the US, they just wake up every morning and go to a job that takes up all their day, then they get married and have kids later on, keep on working, then they retire and lounge around. I hardly call this experiencing all of life's joys and happenings.
Sure, people in this time and age tend to be apathetic, but that doesn't mean all of them are. Ever heard of vacations? Maybe playing a new video game? Or how about learning a new instrument? Each time you experience something new, I'd say that's an achievement all in it's own, no matter how small.

Do you want to be like the 'average person' you've described? I wouldn't want to be.



None.

Sep 18 2009, 9:00 pm Bar Refaeli Post #80



Quote from Greo
Sure, people in this time and age tend to be apathetic, but that doesn't mean all of them are. Ever heard of vacations? Maybe playing a new video game? Or how about learning a new instrument? Each time you experience something new, I'd say that's an achievement all in it's own, no matter how small.

Do you want to be like the 'average person' you've described? I wouldn't want to be.


Destiny still controls us. It controls whether we like the video game or not, or where we want to go to vacation. We make the decisions in our head, but really, there is only one decision for us to make, and we can't make any other ones.

Red: So what is the world if more than 90% of it is "apathetic"
I will still believe in fate until I see one person stand up to fate, and tell the world what is going on, not just himself.



None.

Options
Pages: < 1 « 2 3 4 5 >
  Back to forum
Please log in to reply to this topic or to report it.
Members in this topic: None.
[01:39 am]
Ultraviolet -- no u elky skeleton guy, I'll use em better
[10:50 pm]
Vrael -- Ultraviolet
Ultraviolet shouted: How about you all send me your minerals instead of washing them into the gambling void? I'm saving up for a new name color and/or glow
hey cut it out I'm getting all the minerals
[10:11 pm]
Ultraviolet -- :P
[10:11 pm]
Ultraviolet -- How about you all send me your minerals instead of washing them into the gambling void? I'm saving up for a new name color and/or glow
[2024-4-17. : 11:50 pm]
O)FaRTy1billion[MM] -- nice, now i have more than enough
[2024-4-17. : 11:49 pm]
O)FaRTy1billion[MM] -- if i don't gamble them away first
[2024-4-17. : 11:49 pm]
O)FaRTy1billion[MM] -- o, due to a donation i now have enough minerals to send you minerals
[2024-4-17. : 3:26 am]
O)FaRTy1billion[MM] -- i have to ask for minerals first tho cuz i don't have enough to send
[2024-4-17. : 1:53 am]
Vrael -- bet u'll ask for my minerals first and then just send me some lousy vespene gas instead
[2024-4-17. : 1:52 am]
Vrael -- hah do you think I was born yesterday?
Please log in to shout.


Members Online: Roy, jun3hong